Who’s Responsible for Car Defects After You Buy?

You just bought a car and expected smooth rides ahead. But now there’s a strange noise under the hood, or maybe your dashboard is just suddenly on fire. Who’s responsible for fixing it?

Car defects can come from different sources, some are covered under warranties, some fall under consumer protection laws, and others become the buyer’s responsibility. Knowing who is liable is key to avoiding unexpected repair costs and resolving the issue.

This guide breaks down your rights when buying a used car, the responsibilities of manufacturers and dealers, and what legal options you have if your car turns out to be defective.

Common Types of Car Defects and Their Causes

Not all car defects are created equal! Understanding the type of defect can determine whether you’ll get a free repair or have to pay out of pocket for unexpected expenses. Here’s a breakdown of common car defects and their causes:

Manufacturing Defects

These issues come from errors during the vehicle's production process. Faulty components or poor assembly techniques can cause problems such as engine malfunctions, brake failures, or electrical issues.

Design Defects

When a vehicle’s design poses a safety risk, it’s considered a design defect, i.e. poor engineering choices, such as unstable frames or ineffective airbags, etc.

Software Glitches

Modern cars rely heavily on software for operation. Issues like unintended acceleration or malfunctioning infotainment systems are often due to coding errors or software bugs and can seriously endanger your life.

Wear and Tear

Cars have thousands of pieces holding everything together. Naturally, every piece of heavy equipment degrades over time, and normal aging and usage of a vehicle don't count as defects.

Improper Repairs

Negligence from repair shops can fix one problem and create a hundred new ones.

Understanding these defect types helps clarify who should cover the repair costs, whether it’s the manufacturer, dealer, or you as the owner.

Who is Responsible for Fixing Car Defects?

Responsibility for car defects depends on where the problem originates and the terms of your purchase. While some issues fall under manufacturer or dealer obligations, others may leave the buyer covering repair costs.

Here’s how responsibility breaks down:

Manufacturer Responsibility

If the defect comes from the factory, the manufacturer is usually on the hook. Factory warranties cover defects in materials and workmanship, often for several years or a specific mileage limit. Whereas recalls require manufacturers to repair safety-related defects at no cost, regardless of the vehicle’s age.

What manufacturers don’t cover are the regular wear and tear from daily driving, owner negligence, or damage caused by accidents or modifications.

Dealer Responsibility

A dealership’s liability depends on whether the defect existed before the sale and what kind of warranty was offered.

• If a problem was present before purchase, the dealer may be required to fix it, especially if they misrepresented the vehicle’s condition.
• Certified pre-owned (CPO) warranties mean the dealer must cover specific repairs.
• In many states, dealers selling used cars “as-is” are not responsible for post-sale issues unless fraud or deception is involved.

Buyer Responsibility

When a defect appears after purchase and isn’t covered by a warranty or consumer protection laws, the repair costs typically fall on the owner. If the car was sold as-is, the buyer assumes full responsibility for any issues unless the seller misrepresented its condition. Problems caused by neglect, modifications, or accidents are also not covered under manufacturer or dealer warranties. Some states offer lemon law protections for used cars, but the level of coverage varies.

Negotiating a car deal and understanding where responsibility lies can help you decide whether to push for a free repair or prepare for an out-of-pocket expense.

What If Your Car is a Lemon?

Lemon laws exist to protect buyers from cars with persistent, unfixable defects. If your car spends more time in the shop than on the road, you might be eligible for legal protection.

How Lemon Laws Work

Most lemon laws apply to new cars with major defects that affect safety, value, or drivability. This means that if the manufacturer fails to fix the issue after multiple repair attempts, they must replace the car or issue a refund. Some states go as far as extending lemon law protections to used cars, but coverage depends on the warranty and local regulations.

What You Can Do If You Have a Lemon

How do you know if your car qualifies? If it has a defect that the dealer or manufacturer can’t seem to fix, start tracking your repair history.

• Keep records of all repair attempts. Every service invoice and communication with the dealer or manufacturer matters.
• Check your state’s lemon laws. Some states require a minimum of 3-4 repair attempts or 30+ days in the shop before action can be taken.
• File a complaint with consumer protection agencies. The Better Business Bureau (BBB) and state attorney general’s office can help mediate disputes.
• Consider legal action. If the manufacturer refuses to resolve the issue, you may need to file a legal claim under lemon law protections.

If your car qualifies as a lemon, acting quickly improves your chances of securing a refund or replacement.

How to Check for Recalls and Get Free Repairs

Many defects qualify for free repairs under manufacturer recalls. However, it’s up to the owner to check if their vehicle is affected.

How to Check for Recalls

1. Enter your VIN at NHTSA.gov/recalls, a site that provides a list of any outstanding recalls for your car.
2. Visit the manufacturer’s website where most car brands have a recall lookup tool where you can enter your VIN.
3. Call a local dealership that can confirm if your car has any recalls and schedule a free repair.

What to Do If Your Car Has a Recall

If your car is part of a recall, the manufacturer is required to fix the issue at no cost, even if the vehicle is no longer under warranty. In some cases, if the defect is severe, they may offer a full replacement or buyback instead of a repair.

Safety-related recalls should never be ignored, problems like brake failures or faulty airbags need attention and can help you avoid life-threatening situations and unexpected repair costs.

Checking for recalls regularly can prevent serious problems and save you from costly repairs.

Know Your Rights Before Paying for Repairs

Understanding who is responsible for car defects can save you time, money, and frustration. Whether the issue falls on the manufacturer, dealer, or yourself, knowing your rights helps you take the right steps to get repairs or compensation.

What You Can Do Next

• Check your warranty and recall status to see if repairs are covered.
• Document all issues and repair attempts to strengthen any legal claims.
• Know your options if a dealer or manufacturer refuses to fix a defect.

Need to sell your car fast? List it for free on AutosToday and connect with serious buyers.