Stillwater Auto Sales

2019 Subaru Forester Sport

2018 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium

2018 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT

2018 Ford Escape SE

2018 Honda Fit Sport

2019 Subaru Impreza Premium

2016 Nissan Quest 3.5 SL

2016 Mazda CX-5 Touring

2016 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Sport

2018 Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium

2020 Nissan Rogue SV

2021 Subaru Crosstrek Sport

Heather Swierczek

Our experience was: a transparent guy running a generational family business with a no-hassle purchase for a great deal on a vehicle. Hail damaged vehicles are the cornerstone of this dealership (I think, I don't work there so I could be mistaken) so if you don't mind some exterior flaws, you can get a sweet deal on a mechanically and structurally sound vehicle. The whole thing was super easy, low stress, and with responsive communication. If you require cookies and bubble water in the waiting room, this is not the place for you. If you want an easy deal on a vehicle you can drive for, potentially, quite some time then this is the place for you.

Bryce Suchy

I purchased a Subaru Legacy with hail damage from them 5 years ago and the car is still running great! I also purchased another hail damage vehicle from them just a few months ago, this time a Subaru Outback, and that vehicle has also been running great so far! I have been very happy with both vehicles and will likely be a repeat customer in the future! Definitely a great car buying experience!

Candice Fuller

I purchased a hail damaged 2016 Subaru Forester from Mike. The entire experience from the first contact to the handshake after the purchase was the most positive experience I’ve ever had while purchasing a vehicle. I did my research prior to deciding which vehicle I wanted and Mike never tried to sway me towards a different vehicle. All of our chit chat was very friendly and not pushy or “sales-y” at all. He let me and my dad test drive the vehicle on our own which felt very honest and definitely took the pressure off. Everything that the car needed, like probably soon replacing the tires and pointing out the hail damage and a crack in the back of the trunk door, was pointed out to us very honestly and he gave his professional opinion on things he would replace or not fix in terms of safety and reliability. Mike is super personable and as long as I can help it, I’d never buy a car from anyone else! My new vehicle runs amazing and I could not be happier with my new Subaru!!

Grace Ludowese

My fiancé and I purchased a vehicle from Stillwater Auto Sales and Mike was very great to work with! He made sure that the purchase went smoothly and let us do an inspection prior to purchasing the vehicle! Thank you again for your wonderful service you provided and we will be back to purchase vehicles from you again!! Highly recommend Stillwater Auto Sales to anyone who is in search of a vehicle!

Kyle Wagener

I recently bought my first car at Stillwater Auto Sales and had a really positive experience. I didn't feel pressured and Mike was super friendly, knowledgeable, and communicative. He was also very transparent and upfront about what he knew (and didn't know) about the car based on the Carfax and his own work. He even reached out a few weeks after the purchase to check in on how the car was doing and give me an update on the title.

So far, the car has worked really well and I'm super happy about the purchase. I drove it several hundred miles a couple of days after the purchase to return home and it was a breeze. Mike specializes in hail damaged cars and this one was no exception, but you can barely see any dents anywhere on the car.

Stillwater Auto Sales

Found 12 cars for Stillwater Auto Sales

Make

Mileage & Year

Price & Payment

Deal Rating

Body Type

Exterior Color

Interior Color

Fuel

Drivetrain

Features

Cylinders