Used bmw m5 for Sale near Ithaca, NY
Save search
2023 BMW M5 Base
17,539 mi.
54 days on market
WBS83CH04PCL20228
$88,995
Great Deal
Wyoming Valley Bmw
Wilkes-Barre, PA
4.7
2021 BMW M5 Base
41,010 mi.
12 days on market
WBS83CH0XMCF25955
$66,495
Great Deal
Bmw Of Newton
Newton, NJ
4.8
2019 BMW M5 Competition
58,158 mi.
103 days on market
WBSJF0C57KB448018
$54,990
Lehigh Valley Imports
Bethlehem, PA
4.5
2019 BMW M5 Base
54,141 mi.
11 days on market
WBSJF0C55KB285742
$54,990
Good Deal
Kelly Buick Gmc
Emmaus, PA
4.6
2023 BMW M5 Base
18,338 mi.
31 days on market
WBS83CH06PCL12843
$90,995
Fair Deal
Orange County Bmw
Harriman, NY
4.2
1991 BMW M5
78,870 mi.
25 days on market
WBSHD9311MBK06267
$42,995
Great Deal
Bay 22
Wyomissing, PA
4.9
2026 BMW M5 M5
500 mi.
176 days on market
WBS83FK04TCV95070
$120,000
Good Deal
Bmw Of Reading
Reading, PA
4.6
2022 BMW M5 Base
24,265 mi.
134 days on market
WBS83CH0XNCJ99718
$72,999
Great DealSingle owner
Kia Of Riverdale
Riverdale, NJ
4.4
2023 BMW M5 Base
26,720 mi.
31 days on market
WBS83CH02PCM44787
$94,995
Good DealSingle owner
Sun Motor Cars Bmw
Mechanicsburg, PA
4.5
2022 BMW M5 Base
47,090 mi.
31 days on market
WBS83CH03NCK99000
$79,995
Good DealSingle owner
Sun Motor Cars Bmw
Mechanicsburg, PA
4.5
2023 BMW M5 Base
25,159 mi.
11 days on market
WBS83CH04PCM82294
$84,995
Good Deal
Paul Miller Bmw
Wayne, NJ
4.7
2026 BMW M5 M5
456 mi.
72 days on market
WBS83FK06TCW02276
$119,999
Good Deal
Wide World Bmw
Spring Valley, NY
4.5
1991 BMW M5
77,223 mi.
304 days on market
WBSHD9311MBK05944
$39,500
Great Deal
Hascars
Plumsteadville, PA
5.0
2025 BMW M5 M5
2,385 mi.
54 days on market
WBS83FK09SCT87880
$118,977
Good DealSingle owner
Manheim Imports
Manheim, PA
4.8
2026 BMW M5 M5
1,650 mi.
10 days on market
WBS83FK02TCV07553
$124,988
Great DealSingle owner
Bmw Of Bridgewater
Bridgewater, NJ
4.7
2019 BMW M5 Competition
33,977 mi.
1003 days on market
WBSJF0C59KB448618
$80,977
Good DealClean title
Kelly Motorcars
Hatfield, PA
4.1
2018 BMW M5 Base
56,801 mi.
1230 days on market
WBSJF0C52JB282568
$59,977
Good DealClean title
Kelly Motorcars
Hatfield, PA
4.1
2019 BMW M5 Competition
47,404 mi.
53 days on market
WBSJF0C52KB285875
$72,495
Good Deal
Yosh Motors
Somerville, NJ
4.4
2025 BMW M5 M5 Touring
3,823 mi.
31 days on market
WBS83GV01SCV63788
$141,989
Good Deal
Bmw Of Doylestown
Doylestown, PA
4.7
2022 BMW M5 Base
40,244 mi.
16 days on market
WBS83CH00NCK93607
$80,989
Good Deal
Bmw Of Doylestown
Doylestown, PA
4.7
2018 BMW M5 Base
55,978 mi.
5 days on market
WBSJF0C58JB282235
$49,995
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Faulkner Bmw
Lancaster, PA
4.7
2022 BMW M5 Base
7,398 mi.
49 days on market
WBS83CH09NCK02432
$94,555
Great Deal
Park Avenue Bmw
Rochelle Park, NJ
4.0
2020 BMW M5 Base
53,182 mi.
72 days on market
WBSJF0C06LCD63304
$59,995
Cartopia
North Plainfield, NJ
4.6
2022 BMW M5 Base
40,701 mi.
35 days on market
WBS83CH03NCK72380
$74,998
Good Deal
Bmw Of Bloomfield
Bloomfield, NJ
4.5
2022 BMW M5 Base
22,077 mi.
45 days on market
WBS83CH05NCK96227
$85,999
Good Deal
Rolls Royce Motor Cars Paramus
Paramus, NJ
4.1
2022 BMW M5 Base
29,956 mi.
223 days on market
WBS83CH04NCK35287
$69,251
Great DealSingle owner
Lynnes Hyundai
Bloomfield, NJ
4.2
1993 BMW M5
104,325 mi.
18 days on market
WBSHD9317PBK06567
$18,995
Good Deal
Big Time Auto Sales
Union, NJ
4.6
2022 BMW M5 Base
23,200 mi.
30 days on market
WBS83CH09NCH63667
$83,990
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Bmw Of Springfield
Springfield, NJ
4.6
2023 BMW M5 Base
17,539 mi.
54 days on market
WBS83CH04PCL20228
$88,995
Great Deal
Wyoming Valley Bmw
Wilkes-Barre, PA
4.7
2021 BMW M5 Base
41,010 mi.
12 days on market
WBS83CH0XMCF25955
$66,495
Great Deal
Bmw Of Newton
Newton, NJ
4.8
2019 BMW M5 Competition
58,158 mi.
103 days on market
WBSJF0C57KB448018
$54,990
Lehigh Valley Imports
Bethlehem, PA
4.5
2019 BMW M5 Base
54,141 mi.
11 days on market
WBSJF0C55KB285742
$54,990
Good Deal
Kelly Buick Gmc
Emmaus, PA
4.6
2023 BMW M5 Base
18,338 mi.
31 days on market
WBS83CH06PCL12843
$90,995
Fair Deal
Orange County Bmw
Harriman, NY
4.2
1991 BMW M5
78,870 mi.
25 days on market
WBSHD9311MBK06267
$42,995
Great Deal
Bay 22
Wyomissing, PA
4.9
2026 BMW M5 M5
500 mi.
176 days on market
WBS83FK04TCV95070
$120,000
Good Deal
Bmw Of Reading
Reading, PA
4.6
2022 BMW M5 Base
24,265 mi.
134 days on market
WBS83CH0XNCJ99718
$72,999
Great DealSingle owner
Kia Of Riverdale
Riverdale, NJ
4.4
2023 BMW M5 Base
26,720 mi.
31 days on market
WBS83CH02PCM44787
$94,995
Good DealSingle owner
Sun Motor Cars Bmw
Mechanicsburg, PA
4.5
2022 BMW M5 Base
47,090 mi.
31 days on market
WBS83CH03NCK99000
$79,995
Good DealSingle owner
Sun Motor Cars Bmw
Mechanicsburg, PA
4.5
2023 BMW M5 Base
25,159 mi.
11 days on market
WBS83CH04PCM82294
$84,995
Good Deal
Paul Miller Bmw
Wayne, NJ
4.7
2026 BMW M5 M5
456 mi.
72 days on market
WBS83FK06TCW02276
$119,999
Good Deal
Wide World Bmw
Spring Valley, NY
4.5
1991 BMW M5
77,223 mi.
304 days on market
WBSHD9311MBK05944
$39,500
Great Deal
Hascars
Plumsteadville, PA
5.0
2025 BMW M5 M5
2,385 mi.
54 days on market
WBS83FK09SCT87880
$118,977
Good DealSingle owner
Manheim Imports
Manheim, PA
4.8
2026 BMW M5 M5
1,650 mi.
10 days on market
WBS83FK02TCV07553
$124,988
Great DealSingle owner
Bmw Of Bridgewater
Bridgewater, NJ
4.7
2019 BMW M5 Competition
33,977 mi.
1003 days on market
WBSJF0C59KB448618
$80,977
Good DealClean title
Kelly Motorcars
Hatfield, PA
4.1
2018 BMW M5 Base
56,801 mi.
1230 days on market
WBSJF0C52JB282568
$59,977
Good DealClean title
Kelly Motorcars
Hatfield, PA
4.1
2019 BMW M5 Competition
47,404 mi.
53 days on market
WBSJF0C52KB285875
$72,495
Good Deal
Yosh Motors
Somerville, NJ
4.4
2025 BMW M5 M5 Touring
3,823 mi.
31 days on market
WBS83GV01SCV63788
$141,989
Good Deal
Bmw Of Doylestown
Doylestown, PA
4.7
2022 BMW M5 Base
40,244 mi.
16 days on market
WBS83CH00NCK93607
$80,989
Good Deal
Bmw Of Doylestown
Doylestown, PA
4.7
2018 BMW M5 Base
55,978 mi.
5 days on market
WBSJF0C58JB282235
$49,995
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Faulkner Bmw
Lancaster, PA
4.7
2022 BMW M5 Base
7,398 mi.
49 days on market
WBS83CH09NCK02432
$94,555
Great Deal
Park Avenue Bmw
Rochelle Park, NJ
4.0
2020 BMW M5 Base
53,182 mi.
72 days on market
WBSJF0C06LCD63304
$59,995
Cartopia
North Plainfield, NJ
4.6
2022 BMW M5 Base
40,701 mi.
35 days on market
WBS83CH03NCK72380
$74,998
Good Deal
Bmw Of Bloomfield
Bloomfield, NJ
4.5
2022 BMW M5 Base
22,077 mi.
45 days on market
WBS83CH05NCK96227
$85,999
Good Deal
Rolls Royce Motor Cars Paramus
Paramus, NJ
4.1
2022 BMW M5 Base
29,956 mi.
223 days on market
WBS83CH04NCK35287
$69,251
Great DealSingle owner
Lynnes Hyundai
Bloomfield, NJ
4.2
1993 BMW M5
104,325 mi.
18 days on market
WBSHD9317PBK06567
$18,995
Good Deal
Big Time Auto Sales
Union, NJ
4.6
2022 BMW M5 Base
23,200 mi.
30 days on market
WBS83CH09NCH63667
$83,990
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Bmw Of Springfield
Springfield, NJ
4.6
Find Used BMW M5 in Ithaca, NY
We've got 105 Used BMW M5 vehicles in Ithaca, NY, with prices running from $18,995 to $149,990. Mileage ranges up to 106,205 miles, so you can decide if you want something lightly driven or a more wallet-friendly option.
Nearby BMW M5 for Sale
Used BMW M5 in Lansing, NYUsed BMW M5 in Newfield, NYUsed BMW M5 in Slaterville Springs, NYUsed BMW M5 in Jacksonville, NYUsed BMW M5 in Etna, NYUsed BMW M5 in Brooktondale, NYUsed BMW M5 in Freeville, NYUsed BMW M5 in Willseyville, NYUsed BMW M5 in Mecklenburg, NYUsed BMW M5 in Trumansburg, NYUsed BMW M5 in Alpine, NYUsed BMW M5 in Spencer, NYUsed BMW M5 in Cayuta, NYUsed BMW M5 in Odessa, NYUsed BMW M5 in Dryden, NYUsed BMW M5 in Groton, NYUsed BMW M5 in Harford, NYUsed BMW M5 in Candor, NYUsed BMW M5 in Mc Lean, NYUsed BMW M5 in Van Etten, NYUsed BMW M5 in Burdett, NYUsed BMW M5 in Montour Falls, NYUsed BMW M5 in Interlaken, NYUsed BMW M5 in Erin, NYUsed BMW M5 in Berkshire, NYUsed BMW M5 in Locke, NYUsed BMW M5 in Richford, NYUsed BMW M5 in Hector, NYUsed BMW M5 in King Ferry, NYUsed BMW M5 in Genoa, NYUsed BMW M5 in Breesport, NYUsed BMW M5 in Lockwood, NYUsed BMW M5 in Horseheads, NYUsed BMW M5 in Millport, NYUsed BMW M5 in Lodi, NYUsed BMW M5 in Newark Valley, NYUsed BMW M5 in Reading Center, NYUsed BMW M5 in Pine Valley, NYUsed BMW M5 in Cortland, NYUsed BMW M5 in Lakemont, NYUsed BMW M5 in Rock Stream, NYUsed BMW M5 in Watkins Glen, NYUsed BMW M5 in Marathon, NYUsed BMW M5 in Blodgett Mills, NYUsed BMW M5 in Owego, NYUsed BMW M5 in Barton, NYUsed BMW M5 in Lowman, NYUsed BMW M5 in Poplar Ridge, NYUsed BMW M5 in Aurora, NYUsed BMW M5 in Waverly, NYUsed BMW M5 in Ovid, NYUsed BMW M5 in Moravia, NYUsed BMW M5 in Lisle, NYUsed BMW M5 in Chemung, NYUsed BMW M5 in Beaver Dams, NYUsed BMW M5 in Scipio Center, NYUsed BMW M5 in Killawog, NYUsed BMW M5 in Himrod, NYUsed BMW M5 in Tioga Center, NYUsed BMW M5 in Willard, NYUsed BMW M5 in Dundee, NYUsed BMW M5 in Smithboro, NYUsed BMW M5 in Mc Graw, NYUsed BMW M5 in Mcgraw, NYUsed BMW M5 in Elmira, NYUsed BMW M5 in Nichols, NYUsed BMW M5 in Homer, NYUsed BMW M5 in Maine, NYUsed BMW M5 in East Homer, NYUsed BMW M5 in Tyrone, NYUsed BMW M5 in Glen Aubrey, NYUsed BMW M5 in Big Flats, NYUsed BMW M5 in Wellsburg, NYUsed BMW M5 in Romulus, NYUsed BMW M5 in Penn Yan, NYUsed BMW M5 in Bradford, NYUsed BMW M5 in Dresden, NYUsed BMW M5 in Apalachin, NYUsed BMW M5 in Whitney Point, NYUsed BMW M5 in Wayne, NYUsed BMW M5 in Union Springs, NYUsed BMW M5 in Preble, NYUsed BMW M5 in Johnson City, NYUsed BMW M5 in Sayre, PAUsed BMW M5 in Willet, NYUsed BMW M5 in Bible School Park, NYUsed BMW M5 in Fayette, NYUsed BMW M5 in Hammondsport, NYUsed BMW M5 in Endicott, NYUsed BMW M5 in Cincinnatus, NYUsed BMW M5 in Pine City, NYUsed BMW M5 in Vestal, NYUsed BMW M5 in Endwell, NYUsed BMW M5 in Binghamton, NYUsed BMW M5 in Corning, NYUsed BMW M5 in Castle Creek, NYUsed BMW M5 in Keuka Park, NYUsed BMW M5 in Athens, PAUsed BMW M5 in Pulteney, NY
Other Used BMW models in Ithaca, NY
Used BMW 1 SeriesUsed BMW 2 SeriesUsed BMW 3 SeriesUsed BMW 4 SeriesUsed BMW 5 SeriesUsed BMW 6 SeriesUsed BMW 6 Series ConvertibleUsed BMW 6 Series CoupeUsed BMW 6 Series Gran CoupeUsed BMW 6 Series Gran TurismoUsed BMW 7 SeriesUsed BMW 8 SeriesUsed BMW MUsed BMW M SeriesUsed BMW M2 CoupeUsed BMW M3Used BMW M3 SedanUsed BMW M4Used BMW M4 ConvertibleUsed BMW M4 CoupeUsed BMW M5 SedanUsed BMW M6Used BMW M6 ConvertibleUsed BMW M6 CoupeUsed BMW M6 Gran CoupeUsed BMW M8 ConvertibleUsed BMW M8 CoupeUsed BMW M8 Gran CoupeUsed BMW X1Used BMW X2Used BMW X3Used BMW X3 MUsed BMW X4Used BMW X4 MUsed BMW X5Used BMW X5 MUsed BMW X6Used BMW X6 MUsed BMW X7Used BMW XMUsed BMW Z3Used BMW Z4Used BMW Z8Used BMW i3Used BMW i4Used BMW i5Used BMW i7Used BMW i8Used BMW iX