Used Cars for Sale near Bay Shore, NY
Save search
2020 Lincoln MKZ Reserve I
76,959 mi.
47 days on market
3LN6L5LU9LR604045
$20,516
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Jeep Gladiator Overland
37,126 mi.
125 days on market
1C6HJTFG4ML573503
$30,397
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2020 Ford Explorer XLT
56,089 mi.
146 days on market
1FMSK8DH2LGB79473
$21,700
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2022 Honda CR-V EX
10,731 mi.
4 days on market
2HKRW2H50NH612534
$23,984
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Mazda CX-5 S Preferred package
41,262 mi.
104 days on market
JM3KFBCM2P0148136
$23,499
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2025 Mazda CX-5 S Preferred package
6,389 mi.
17 days on market
JM3KFBCL5S0607224
$28,998
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2024 Honda HR-V Sport
50,979 mi.
32 days on market
3CZRZ2H50RM745957
$22,993
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2019 Volvo XC60 R-Design
56,302 mi.
47 days on market
LYVA22RMXKB215780
$22,988
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Lincoln Nautilus Reserve
28,245 mi.
152 days on market
2LMPJ8K90MBL14323
$33,997
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2020 Lincoln Navigator Reserve
34,768 mi.
17 days on market
5LMJJ2LT5LEL17792
$45,997
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2019 Cadillac XT5 Luxury
59,128 mi.
59 days on market
1GYKNDRS0KZ277536
$20,357
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2020 Lincoln Corsair Base
37,985 mi.
11 days on market
5LMCJ1D99LUL19590
$23,994
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Audi A5 Sportback Premium Plus
18,036 mi.
41 days on market
WAUCBCF54PA017302
$34,988
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2025 Lincoln Corsair Premiere
2,836 mi.
8 days on market
5LMCJ1DA0SUL20166
$48,020
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Volkswagen Tiguan SE R-LINE BLACK
33,258 mi.
47 days on market
3VV2B7AX4MM127264
$20,803
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Lincoln Nautilus Reserve
33,730 mi.
48 days on market
2LMPJ8K92MBL14744
$31,499
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Lincoln Corsair Base
21,752 mi.
131 days on market
5LMCJ1D91MUL16975
$25,899
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Cadillac XT6 Premium Luxury
30,020 mi.
62 days on market
1GYKPDRS2PZ117207
$35,427
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Lincoln Corsair Reserve
46,851 mi.
33 days on market
5LMCJ2D95MUL26978
$27,717
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Mazda CX-5 S
53,866 mi.
55 days on market
JM3KFBAM6P0205053
$21,673
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2025 Mazda CX-5 S Carbon Edition
4,802 mi.
25 days on market
JM3KFBCM7S0646812
$29,983
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2019 Mazda CX-9 Touring
91,817 mi.
48 days on market
JM3TCBCY9K0311163
$15,998
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2024 Ford Edge SEL
38,258 mi.
67 days on market
2FMPK4J90RBA77276
$22,728
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Mazda CX-5 S
34,988 mi.
104 days on market
JM3KFBAM6P0159790
$22,398
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Lincoln Nautilus Reserve
35,176 mi.
20 days on market
2LMPJ8K91PBL04081
$38,390
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2024 Mazda CX-50 S PREMIUM
35,913 mi.
17 days on market
7MMVABDM0RN169477
$25,498
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2019 Ford Explorer XLT
74,375 mi.
33 days on market
1FM5K8D89KGA34619
$17,349
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2022 Ford Expedition Limited
38,356 mi.
107 days on market
1FMJK2AT8NEA31487
$54,499
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2020 Lincoln MKZ Reserve I
76,959 mi.
47 days on market
3LN6L5LU9LR604045
$20,516
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Jeep Gladiator Overland
37,126 mi.
125 days on market
1C6HJTFG4ML573503
$30,397
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2020 Ford Explorer XLT
56,089 mi.
146 days on market
1FMSK8DH2LGB79473
$21,700
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2022 Honda CR-V EX
10,731 mi.
4 days on market
2HKRW2H50NH612534
$23,984
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Mazda CX-5 S Preferred package
41,262 mi.
104 days on market
JM3KFBCM2P0148136
$23,499
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2025 Mazda CX-5 S Preferred package
6,389 mi.
17 days on market
JM3KFBCL5S0607224
$28,998
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2024 Honda HR-V Sport
50,979 mi.
32 days on market
3CZRZ2H50RM745957
$22,993
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2019 Volvo XC60 R-Design
56,302 mi.
47 days on market
LYVA22RMXKB215780
$22,988
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Lincoln Nautilus Reserve
28,245 mi.
152 days on market
2LMPJ8K90MBL14323
$33,997
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2020 Lincoln Navigator Reserve
34,768 mi.
17 days on market
5LMJJ2LT5LEL17792
$45,997
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2019 Cadillac XT5 Luxury
59,128 mi.
59 days on market
1GYKNDRS0KZ277536
$20,357
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2020 Lincoln Corsair Base
37,985 mi.
11 days on market
5LMCJ1D99LUL19590
$23,994
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Audi A5 Sportback Premium Plus
18,036 mi.
41 days on market
WAUCBCF54PA017302
$34,988
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2025 Lincoln Corsair Premiere
2,836 mi.
8 days on market
5LMCJ1DA0SUL20166
$48,020
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Volkswagen Tiguan SE R-LINE BLACK
33,258 mi.
47 days on market
3VV2B7AX4MM127264
$20,803
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Lincoln Nautilus Reserve
33,730 mi.
48 days on market
2LMPJ8K92MBL14744
$31,499
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Lincoln Corsair Base
21,752 mi.
131 days on market
5LMCJ1D91MUL16975
$25,899
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Cadillac XT6 Premium Luxury
30,020 mi.
62 days on market
1GYKPDRS2PZ117207
$35,427
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2021 Lincoln Corsair Reserve
46,851 mi.
33 days on market
5LMCJ2D95MUL26978
$27,717
Fair Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Mazda CX-5 S
53,866 mi.
55 days on market
JM3KFBAM6P0205053
$21,673
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2025 Mazda CX-5 S Carbon Edition
4,802 mi.
25 days on market
JM3KFBCM7S0646812
$29,983
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2019 Mazda CX-9 Touring
91,817 mi.
48 days on market
JM3TCBCY9K0311163
$15,998
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2024 Ford Edge SEL
38,258 mi.
67 days on market
2FMPK4J90RBA77276
$22,728
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Mazda CX-5 S
34,988 mi.
104 days on market
JM3KFBAM6P0159790
$22,398
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2023 Lincoln Nautilus Reserve
35,176 mi.
20 days on market
2LMPJ8K91PBL04081
$38,390
Good Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2024 Mazda CX-50 S PREMIUM
35,913 mi.
17 days on market
7MMVABDM0RN169477
$25,498
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2019 Ford Explorer XLT
74,375 mi.
33 days on market
1FM5K8D89KGA34619
$17,349
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
2022 Ford Expedition Limited
38,356 mi.
107 days on market
1FMJK2AT8NEA31487
$54,499
Great Deal
Bright Bay Lincoln
Bay Shore, NY
4.7
Nearby Cities
Used Cars in Brightwaters, NYUsed Cars in West Islip, NYUsed Cars in Islip, NYUsed Cars in North Babylon, NYUsed Cars in Brentwood, NYUsed Cars in Deer Park, NYUsed Cars in East Islip, NYUsed Cars in Central Islip, NYUsed Cars in West Babylon, NYUsed Cars in Islip Terrace, NYUsed Cars in Great River, NYUsed Cars in Wyandanch, NYUsed Cars in Lindenhurst, NYUsed Cars in Hauppauge, NYUsed Cars in Islandia, NYUsed Cars in Oakdale, NYUsed Cars in Commack, NYUsed Cars in Huntington Station, NYUsed Cars in Bohemia, NYUsed Cars in Copiague, NYUsed Cars in Ocean Beach, NYUsed Cars in Farmingdale, NYUsed Cars in West Sayville, NYUsed Cars in Melville, NYUsed Cars in Babylon, NYUsed Cars in Smithtown, NYUsed Cars in East Northport, NYUsed Cars in Sayville, NYUsed Cars in Ronkonkoma, NYUsed Cars in Nesconset, NYUsed Cars in Old Bethpage, NYUsed Cars in Massapequa Park, NYUsed Cars in Greenlawn, NYUsed Cars in Kings Park, NYUsed Cars in Plainview, NYUsed Cars in Bayport, NYUsed Cars in Massapequa, NYUsed Cars in Holbrook, NYUsed Cars in Bethpage, NYUsed Cars in Lake Grove, NYUsed Cars in Saint James, NYUsed Cars in Blue Point, NYUsed Cars in Woodbury, NYUsed Cars in Centerport, NYUsed Cars in Seaford, NYUsed Cars in Northport, NYUsed Cars in Holtsville, NYUsed Cars in Huntington, NYUsed Cars in Cold Spring Harbor, NYUsed Cars in Levittown, NYUsed Cars in Centereach, NYUsed Cars in Wantagh, NYUsed Cars in Stony Brook, NYUsed Cars in Farmingville, NYUsed Cars in Syosset, NYUsed Cars in Patchogue, NYUsed Cars in Bellmore, NYUsed Cars in Selden, NYUsed Cars in Jericho, NYUsed Cars in East Meadow, NYUsed Cars in Merrick, NYUsed Cars in East Norwich, NYUsed Cars in Medford, NYUsed Cars in Oyster Bay, NYUsed Cars in East Setauket, NYUsed Cars in Coram, NYUsed Cars in Bellport, NYUsed Cars in Roosevelt, NYUsed Cars in Uniondale, NYUsed Cars in Port Jefferson Station, NYUsed Cars in Freeport, NYUsed Cars in Hempstead, NYUsed Cars in Hicksville, NYUsed Cars in Port Washington, NYUsed Cars in Westbury, NYUsed Cars in Old Westbury, NYUsed Cars in Glen Head, NYUsed Cars in Carle Place, NYUsed Cars in Port Jefferson, NYUsed Cars in Mill Neck, NYUsed Cars in Baldwin, NYUsed Cars in Brookhaven, NYUsed Cars in Mount Sinai, NYUsed Cars in Point Lookout, NYUsed Cars in Middle Island, NYUsed Cars in Garden City, NYUsed Cars in Bayville, NYUsed Cars in Mineola, NYUsed Cars in Greenvale, NYUsed Cars in Locust Valley, NYUsed Cars in Yaphank, NYUsed Cars in Williston Park, NYUsed Cars in Roslyn Heights, NYUsed Cars in Rockville Centre, NYUsed Cars in West Hempstead, NYUsed Cars in Albertson, NYUsed Cars in Miller Place, NYUsed Cars in Shirley, NYUsed Cars in Glenwood Landing, NY
All Makes in Bay Shore, NY
Used AMCUsed AcuraUsed Alfa RomeoUsed Am GeneralUsed Aston MartinUsed AudiUsed BMWUsed BentleyUsed BintelliUsed BugattiUsed BuickUsed CadillacUsed Can-AmUsed ChevroletUsed ChryslerUsed DaewooUsed DatsunUsed DodgeUsed DucatiUsed EagleUsed FIATUsed FerrariUsed FiskerUsed FordUsed FreightlinerUsed GENESISUsed GMCUsed GeoUsed Harley-DavidsonUsed HondaUsed HummerUsed HyundaiUsed INEOSUsed INFINITIUsed InternationalUsed IsuzuUsed JaguarUsed JeepUsed KARMAUsed KawasakiUsed KenworthUsed KiaUsed LamborghiniUsed Land RoverUsed LexusUsed LincolnUsed LotusUsed LucidUsed MINIUsed MaseratiUsed MaybachUsed MazdaUsed McLarenUsed Mercedes-BenzUsed MercuryUsed MitsubishiUsed NissanUsed OldsmobileUsed PeterbiltUsed PlymouthUsed PolarisUsed PolestarUsed PontiacUsed PorscheUsed RAMUsed RivianUsed Rolls-RoyceUsed SaabUsed SaturnUsed ScionUsed SterlingUsed SubaruUsed SuzukiUsed TeslaUsed ToyotaUsed VinFastUsed VolkswagenUsed VolvoUsed YamahaUsed smart
Car Body Types in Bay Shore, NY
Cars by Price in Bay Shore, NY
Used Cars Under $2,000Used Cars Under $3,000Used Cars Under $4,000Used Cars Under $5,000Used Cars Under $6,000Used Cars Under $7,000Used Cars Under $8,000Used Cars Under $9,000Used Cars Under $10,000Used Cars Under $11,000Used Cars Under $12,000Used Cars Under $13,000Used Cars Under $14,000Used Cars Under $15,000Used Cars Under $16,000Used Cars Under $17,000Used Cars Under $18,000Used Cars Under $19,000Used Cars Under $20,000Used Cars Under $21,000Used Cars Under $22,000Used Cars Under $23,000Used Cars Under $24,000Used Cars Under $25,000Used Cars Under $26,000Used Cars Under $27,000Used Cars Under $28,000Used Cars Under $29,000Used Cars Under $30,000