Used subaru forester for Sale near Eldred, NY
Save search
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
109,497 mi.
168 days on market
JF2SKAJC1LH472295
$23,995
Seven X Motors Inc
Mongaup Valley, NY
4.1
2017 Subaru Forester Premium
124,088 mi.
161 days on market
JF2SJAEC1HH515778
$17,777
Good Deal
Seven X Motors Inc
Mongaup Valley, NY
4.1
2015 Subaru Forester i Premium
93,790 mi.
129 days on market
JF2SJADC1FH813004
$13,995
Good Deal
Special H Motors
Monticello, NY
4.9
2012 Subaru Forester X Premium Package
66,125 mi.
179 days on market
JF2SHADC1CH422569
$12,500
Good Deal
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2016 Subaru Forester XT Premium
121,500 mi.
5 days on market
JF2SJGDCXGH461965
$11,995
Good DealClean title
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2010 Subaru Forester X Limited
88,389 mi.
130 days on market
JF2SH6DC5AH914922
$9,895
Clean title
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2012 Subaru Forester XT Touring
105,030 mi.
112 days on market
JF2SHGGC3CH416903
$12,500
Great DealClean title
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2011 Subaru Forester X Premium Package
65,612 mi.
119 days on market
JF2SHADC4BH730866
$11,995
Great Deal
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2021 Subaru Forester Premium
56,496 mi.
30 days on market
JF2SKAJC6MH593650
$21,654
Good DealSingle owner
Middletown Volkswagen
Middletown, NY
4.7
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
24,072 mi.
62 days on market
JF2SLDBC9SH413801
$28,800
Good Deal
Healey Mitsubishi
Middletown, NY
4.7
2021 Subaru Forester Touring
136,500 mi.
108 days on market
JF2SKAXC1MH403616
$19,490
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2024 Subaru Forester Sport
14,212 mi.
221 days on market
JF2SKAGC9RH509657
$33,490
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2023 Subaru Forester Sport
24,531 mi.
28 days on market
JF2SKAGC1PH499641
$26,990
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2021 Subaru Forester Sport
48,157 mi.
13 days on market
JF2SKARC5MH456980
$24,990
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2022 Subaru Forester Touring
3,090 mi.
55 days on market
JF2SKARC6NH526407
$31,990
Fair Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
61,097 mi.
96 days on market
JF2SKAGC0LH517573
$22,490
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2024 Subaru Forester Touring
17,929 mi.
175 days on market
JF2SKAMC5RH416297
$33,990
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2019 Subaru Forester Limited
142,976 mi.
6 days on market
JF2SKAUC4KH405829
Contact Dealer
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2020 Subaru Forester Limited
62,492 mi.
107 days on market
JF2SKAUCXLH440649
$24,990
Fair Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
7,793 mi.
104 days on market
JF2SLDBC6SH470800
$32,990
Fair Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2024 Subaru Forester Sport
17,904 mi.
230 days on market
JF2SKAGC7RH490994
$31,490
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
9,111 mi.
9 days on market
JF2SLDHC6SH505813
$38,836
Great Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
8,008 mi.
203 days on market
JF2SLDHC2SH489786
$35,990
Great Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Limited
7,037 mi.
231 days on market
JF2SLDRC5SH435672
$35,490
Fair Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2021 Subaru Forester Limited
67,478 mi.
133 days on market
JF2SKASCXMH404044
$25,990
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
7,513 mi.
9 days on market
JF2SLDBC1SH470543
$32,990
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2023 Subaru Forester Touring
46,750 mi.
12 days on market
JF2SKARC0PH480995
$29,490
Great Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2019 Subaru Forester Sport
60,983 mi.
5 days on market
JF2SKAPC1KH402124
Contact Dealer
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
109,497 mi.
168 days on market
JF2SKAJC1LH472295
$23,995
Seven X Motors Inc
Mongaup Valley, NY
4.1
2017 Subaru Forester Premium
124,088 mi.
161 days on market
JF2SJAEC1HH515778
$17,777
Good Deal
Seven X Motors Inc
Mongaup Valley, NY
4.1
2015 Subaru Forester i Premium
93,790 mi.
129 days on market
JF2SJADC1FH813004
$13,995
Good Deal
Special H Motors
Monticello, NY
4.9
2012 Subaru Forester X Premium Package
66,125 mi.
179 days on market
JF2SHADC1CH422569
$12,500
Good Deal
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2016 Subaru Forester XT Premium
121,500 mi.
5 days on market
JF2SJGDCXGH461965
$11,995
Good DealClean title
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2010 Subaru Forester X Limited
88,389 mi.
130 days on market
JF2SH6DC5AH914922
$9,895
Clean title
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2012 Subaru Forester XT Touring
105,030 mi.
112 days on market
JF2SHGGC3CH416903
$12,500
Great DealClean title
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2011 Subaru Forester X Premium Package
65,612 mi.
119 days on market
JF2SHADC4BH730866
$11,995
Great Deal
Schaffer Automotive Inc
Slate Hill, NY
4.6
2021 Subaru Forester Premium
56,496 mi.
30 days on market
JF2SKAJC6MH593650
$21,654
Good DealSingle owner
Middletown Volkswagen
Middletown, NY
4.7
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
24,072 mi.
62 days on market
JF2SLDBC9SH413801
$28,800
Good Deal
Healey Mitsubishi
Middletown, NY
4.7
2021 Subaru Forester Touring
136,500 mi.
108 days on market
JF2SKAXC1MH403616
$19,490
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2024 Subaru Forester Sport
14,212 mi.
221 days on market
JF2SKAGC9RH509657
$33,490
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2023 Subaru Forester Sport
24,531 mi.
28 days on market
JF2SKAGC1PH499641
$26,990
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2021 Subaru Forester Sport
48,157 mi.
13 days on market
JF2SKARC5MH456980
$24,990
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2022 Subaru Forester Touring
3,090 mi.
55 days on market
JF2SKARC6NH526407
$31,990
Fair Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
61,097 mi.
96 days on market
JF2SKAGC0LH517573
$22,490
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2024 Subaru Forester Touring
17,929 mi.
175 days on market
JF2SKAMC5RH416297
$33,990
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2019 Subaru Forester Limited
142,976 mi.
6 days on market
JF2SKAUC4KH405829
Contact Dealer
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2020 Subaru Forester Limited
62,492 mi.
107 days on market
JF2SKAUCXLH440649
$24,990
Fair Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
7,793 mi.
104 days on market
JF2SLDBC6SH470800
$32,990
Fair Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2024 Subaru Forester Sport
17,904 mi.
230 days on market
JF2SKAGC7RH490994
$31,490
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
9,111 mi.
9 days on market
JF2SLDHC6SH505813
$38,836
Great Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
8,008 mi.
203 days on market
JF2SLDHC2SH489786
$35,990
Great Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Limited
7,037 mi.
231 days on market
JF2SLDRC5SH435672
$35,490
Fair Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2021 Subaru Forester Limited
67,478 mi.
133 days on market
JF2SKASCXMH404044
$25,990
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
7,513 mi.
9 days on market
JF2SLDBC1SH470543
$32,990
Good Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2023 Subaru Forester Touring
46,750 mi.
12 days on market
JF2SKARC0PH480995
$29,490
Great Deal
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
2019 Subaru Forester Sport
60,983 mi.
5 days on market
JF2SKAPC1KH402124
Contact Dealer
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
4.4
Find Used Subaru Forester in Eldred, NY
We've got 5,692 Used Subaru Forester vehicles in Eldred, NY, with prices running from $1,999 to $46,170. Mileage ranges up to 1,186,100 miles, so you can decide if you want something lightly driven or a more wallet-friendly option.
Nearby Subaru Forester for Sale
Used Subaru Forester in Highland Lake, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Yulan, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Barryville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Glen Spey, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Bethel, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Narrowsburg, NYUsed Subaru Forester in White Lake, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Pond Eddy, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Lackawaxen, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Smallwood, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Forestburgh, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Cochecton Center, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Mongaup Valley, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Shohola, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Cochecton, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Rowland, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Kauneonga Lake, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Millrift, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Lake Huntington, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Greeley, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Sparrow Bush, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Beach Lake, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Monticello, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Kenoza Lake, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Harris, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Swan Lake, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Matamoras, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Cuddebackville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Damascus, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Milanville, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Milford, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Ferndale, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Huguenot, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Kiamesha Lake, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Thompsonville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Jeffersonville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Rock Hill, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Tyler Hill, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Hortonville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in White Mills, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Hawley, PAUsed Subaru Forester in South Fallsburg, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Westbrookville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Silver Spring, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Port Jervis, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Callicoon, NYUsed Subaru Forester in White Sulphur Springs, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Hurleyville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Youngsville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Tafton, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Fallsburg, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Otisville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Glen Wild, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Woodridge, NYUsed Subaru Forester in North Branch, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Wurtsboro, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Loch Sheldrake, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Montague, NJUsed Subaru Forester in Liberty, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Honesdale, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Callicoon Center, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Mountain Dale, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Hamlin, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Paupack, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Lakeville, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Obernburg, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Fremont Center, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Howells, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Greenfield Park, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Middletown, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Hankins, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Bloomingburg, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Woodbourne, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Summitville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Westtown, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Johnson, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Phillipsport, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Parksville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Greentown, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Unionville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Dingmans Ferry, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Equinunk, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Prompton, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Slate Hill, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Spring Glen, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Neversink, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Branchville, NJUsed Subaru Forester in Sussex, NJUsed Subaru Forester in Burlingham, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Circleville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in New Hampton, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Ellenville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Waymart, PAUsed Subaru Forester in Layton, NJUsed Subaru Forester in Long Eddy, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Walker Valley, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Pine Island, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Bullville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Canadensis, PA
Other Used Subaru models in Eldred, NY
Used Subaru AscentUsed Subaru B9 TribecaUsed Subaru BRZUsed Subaru BajaUsed Subaru CrosstrekUsed Subaru DLUsed Subaru GLUsed Subaru ImprezaUsed Subaru Impreza SedanUsed Subaru Impreza Sedan WRXUsed Subaru JustyUsed Subaru LegacyUsed Subaru LoyaleUsed Subaru OutbackUsed Subaru SOLTERRAUsed Subaru SVXUsed Subaru TribecaUsed Subaru WRXUsed Subaru WRX STIUsed Subaru XV CrosstrekUsed Subaru XV Crosstrek Hybrid
All Years for Used Subaru Forester in Eldred, NY
Used Subaru Forester 1998Used Subaru Forester 1999Used Subaru Forester 2000Used Subaru Forester 2001Used Subaru Forester 2002Used Subaru Forester 2003Used Subaru Forester 2004Used Subaru Forester 2005Used Subaru Forester 2006Used Subaru Forester 2007Used Subaru Forester 2008Used Subaru Forester 2009Used Subaru Forester 2010Used Subaru Forester 2011Used Subaru Forester 2012Used Subaru Forester 2013Used Subaru Forester 2014Used Subaru Forester 2015Used Subaru Forester 2016Used Subaru Forester 2017Used Subaru Forester 2018Used Subaru Forester 2019Used Subaru Forester 2020Used Subaru Forester 2021Used Subaru Forester 2022Used Subaru Forester 2023Used Subaru Forester 2024Used Subaru Forester 2025Used Subaru Forester 2026