Used subaru forester for Sale near Middlesex, NY
Save search
2022 Subaru Forester Wilderness
0 mi.
106 days on market
JF2SKAMC9NH529972
$27,344
Good DealSingle owner
Friendly Cdjr
Penn Yan, NY
4.7
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
61,256 mi.
64 days on market
JF2SKAJC2LH580585
$20,589
Canandaigua Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
Canandaigua, NY
4.4
2019 Subaru Forester Premium
65,785 mi.
20 days on market
JF2SKAGC7KH470394
$20,145
Great DealClean title
Vision Kia Canandaigua
Canandaigua, NY
4.5
2024 Subaru Forester Wilderness
16,460 mi.
80 days on market
JF2SKAJC4RH426842
$30,895
Fair DealClean title
Friendly Cdjr Geneva
Geneva, NY
4.7
2015 Subaru Forester i Limited
122,286 mi.
24 days on market
JF2SJAHC8FH537334
$10,995
Good Deal
Hagen Automotive
Bloomfield, NY
4.9
2016 Subaru Forester i Premium
134,653 mi.
23 days on market
JF2SJAFC3GH477919
$10,995
Good Deal
Hagen Automotive
Bloomfield, NY
4.9
2015 Subaru Forester i Premium
136,787 mi.
351 days on market
JF2SJADC0FH820218
$9,995
Good Deal
Hagen Automotive
Bloomfield, NY
4.9
2015 Subaru Forester i Premium
135,205 mi.
11 days on market
JF2SJADC2FH550859
$9,995
Great Deal
Hagen Automotive
Bloomfield, NY
4.9
2021 Subaru Forester Limited
62,189 mi.
92 days on market
JF2SKAUC1MH407198
$23,735
Auto Outlets Usa
Farmington, NY
4.4
2023 Subaru Forester Sport
56,862 mi.
74 days on market
JF2SKAGC6PH444926
$26,100
Fair Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2021 Subaru Forester Premium
54,254 mi.
44 days on market
JF2SKAFC0MH449455
$23,700
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
7,987 mi.
18 days on market
JF2SLDDC6SH424364
$34,300
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
25,134 mi.
23 days on market
JF2SKAECXPH415917
$28,100
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2022 Subaru Forester Premium
44,747 mi.
21 days on market
JF2SKADC9NH432268
$24,700
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2021 Subaru Forester Base
44,445 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SKADC7MH518533
$20,800
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Limited
35,454 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SKAPC3PH401273
$29,100
Fair Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
4,782 mi.
109 days on market
JF2SLDBC3SH496402
$32,600
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2020 Subaru Forester Limited
74,206 mi.
74 days on market
JF2SKAUC1LH405028
$22,500
Fair Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
8,731 mi.
170 days on market
JF2SLDBCXSH422135
$32,300
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
40,177 mi.
37 days on market
JF2SKAEC8PH452741
$26,900
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Touring
33,696 mi.
21 days on market
JF2SKARC9PH431049
$30,100
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2022 Subaru Forester Limited
22,353 mi.
23 days on market
JF2SKANC5NH421136
$28,100
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
9,288 mi.
106 days on market
JF2SLDBC1SH455461
$32,300
Fair Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2021 Subaru Forester Limited
57,632 mi.
48 days on market
JF2SKAUC8MH531159
$23,700
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
55,704 mi.
11 days on market
JF2SKAEC9PH461514
$25,300
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
8,512 mi.
102 days on market
JF2SLDBC4SH480211
$32,300
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
8,502 mi.
109 days on market
JF2SLDBC5SH477804
$32,300
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2022 Subaru Forester Limited
34,213 mi.
29 days on market
JF2SKAPC5NH520858
$27,100
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2022 Subaru Forester Wilderness
0 mi.
106 days on market
JF2SKAMC9NH529972
$27,344
Good DealSingle owner
Friendly Cdjr
Penn Yan, NY
4.7
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
61,256 mi.
64 days on market
JF2SKAJC2LH580585
$20,589
Canandaigua Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
Canandaigua, NY
4.4
2019 Subaru Forester Premium
65,785 mi.
20 days on market
JF2SKAGC7KH470394
$20,145
Great DealClean title
Vision Kia Canandaigua
Canandaigua, NY
4.5
2024 Subaru Forester Wilderness
16,460 mi.
80 days on market
JF2SKAJC4RH426842
$30,895
Fair DealClean title
Friendly Cdjr Geneva
Geneva, NY
4.7
2015 Subaru Forester i Limited
122,286 mi.
24 days on market
JF2SJAHC8FH537334
$10,995
Good Deal
Hagen Automotive
Bloomfield, NY
4.9
2016 Subaru Forester i Premium
134,653 mi.
23 days on market
JF2SJAFC3GH477919
$10,995
Good Deal
Hagen Automotive
Bloomfield, NY
4.9
2015 Subaru Forester i Premium
136,787 mi.
351 days on market
JF2SJADC0FH820218
$9,995
Good Deal
Hagen Automotive
Bloomfield, NY
4.9
2015 Subaru Forester i Premium
135,205 mi.
11 days on market
JF2SJADC2FH550859
$9,995
Great Deal
Hagen Automotive
Bloomfield, NY
4.9
2021 Subaru Forester Limited
62,189 mi.
92 days on market
JF2SKAUC1MH407198
$23,735
Auto Outlets Usa
Farmington, NY
4.4
2023 Subaru Forester Sport
56,862 mi.
74 days on market
JF2SKAGC6PH444926
$26,100
Fair Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2021 Subaru Forester Premium
54,254 mi.
44 days on market
JF2SKAFC0MH449455
$23,700
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
7,987 mi.
18 days on market
JF2SLDDC6SH424364
$34,300
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
25,134 mi.
23 days on market
JF2SKAECXPH415917
$28,100
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2022 Subaru Forester Premium
44,747 mi.
21 days on market
JF2SKADC9NH432268
$24,700
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2021 Subaru Forester Base
44,445 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SKADC7MH518533
$20,800
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Limited
35,454 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SKAPC3PH401273
$29,100
Fair Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
4,782 mi.
109 days on market
JF2SLDBC3SH496402
$32,600
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2020 Subaru Forester Limited
74,206 mi.
74 days on market
JF2SKAUC1LH405028
$22,500
Fair Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
8,731 mi.
170 days on market
JF2SLDBCXSH422135
$32,300
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
40,177 mi.
37 days on market
JF2SKAEC8PH452741
$26,900
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Touring
33,696 mi.
21 days on market
JF2SKARC9PH431049
$30,100
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2022 Subaru Forester Limited
22,353 mi.
23 days on market
JF2SKANC5NH421136
$28,100
Good Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
9,288 mi.
106 days on market
JF2SLDBC1SH455461
$32,300
Fair Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2021 Subaru Forester Limited
57,632 mi.
48 days on market
JF2SKAUC8MH531159
$23,700
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
55,704 mi.
11 days on market
JF2SKAEC9PH461514
$25,300
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
8,512 mi.
102 days on market
JF2SLDBC4SH480211
$32,300
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
8,502 mi.
109 days on market
JF2SLDBC5SH477804
$32,300
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
2022 Subaru Forester Limited
34,213 mi.
29 days on market
JF2SKAPC5NH520858
$27,100
Great Deal
Van Bortel Subaru Of Victor
Victor, NY
4.8
Find Used Subaru Forester in Middlesex, NY
We've got 4,460 Used Subaru Forester vehicles in Middlesex, NY, with prices running from $1,999 to $46,172. Mileage ranges up to 284,659 miles, so you can decide if you want something lightly driven or a more wallet-friendly option.
Nearby Subaru Forester for Sale
Used Subaru Forester in Rushville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Branchport, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Naples, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Gorham, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Keuka Park, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Canandaigua, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Stanley, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Hall, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Pulteney, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Bellona, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Prattsburgh, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Penn Yan, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Honeoye, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Dresden, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Atlanta, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Seneca Castle, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Geneva, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Himrod, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Wayne, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Bloomfield, NYUsed Subaru Forester in East Bloomfield, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Springwater, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Dundee, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Hammondsport, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Hemlock, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Willard, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Wayland, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Manchester, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Clifton Springs, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Shortsville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Cohocton, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Lakemont, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Oaks Corners, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Romulus, NYUsed Subaru Forester in West Bloomfield, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Livonia, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Ionia, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Farmington, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Tyrone, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Avoca, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Phelps, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Lodi, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Conesus, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Rock Stream, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Ovid, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Livonia Center, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Perkinsville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Victor, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Lima, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Kanona, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Fayette, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Bath, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Hector, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Scottsburg, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Reading Center, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Port Gibson, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Bradford, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Fishers, NYUsed Subaru Forester in South Lima, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Waterloo, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Mendon, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Palmyra, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Lakeville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Savona, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Dansville, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Seneca Falls, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Watkins Glen, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Honeoye Falls, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Interlaken, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Burdett, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Groveland, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Newark, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Geneseo, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Pittsford, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Macedon, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Rush, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Avon, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Aurora, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Fairport, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Lyons, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Sonyea, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Beaver Dams, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Henrietta, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Trumansburg, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Cayuga, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Montour Falls, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Union Springs, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Mecklenburg, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Arkport, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Walworth, NYUsed Subaru Forester in East Rochester, NYUsed Subaru Forester in King Ferry, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Poplar Ridge, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Campbell, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Marion, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Odessa, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Mount Morris, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Nunda, NYUsed Subaru Forester in Penfield, NY
Other Used Subaru models in Middlesex, NY
Used Subaru AscentUsed Subaru B9 TribecaUsed Subaru BRZUsed Subaru BajaUsed Subaru CrosstrekUsed Subaru DLUsed Subaru GLUsed Subaru ImprezaUsed Subaru Impreza SedanUsed Subaru Impreza Sedan WRXUsed Subaru JustyUsed Subaru LegacyUsed Subaru LoyaleUsed Subaru OutbackUsed Subaru SOLTERRAUsed Subaru SVXUsed Subaru TribecaUsed Subaru WRXUsed Subaru WRX STIUsed Subaru XV CrosstrekUsed Subaru XV Crosstrek Hybrid
All Years for Used Subaru Forester in Middlesex, NY
Used Subaru Forester 1998Used Subaru Forester 1999Used Subaru Forester 2000Used Subaru Forester 2001Used Subaru Forester 2002Used Subaru Forester 2003Used Subaru Forester 2004Used Subaru Forester 2005Used Subaru Forester 2006Used Subaru Forester 2007Used Subaru Forester 2008Used Subaru Forester 2009Used Subaru Forester 2010Used Subaru Forester 2011Used Subaru Forester 2012Used Subaru Forester 2013Used Subaru Forester 2014Used Subaru Forester 2015Used Subaru Forester 2016Used Subaru Forester 2017Used Subaru Forester 2018Used Subaru Forester 2019Used Subaru Forester 2020Used Subaru Forester 2021Used Subaru Forester 2022Used Subaru Forester 2023Used Subaru Forester 2024Used Subaru Forester 2025Used Subaru Forester 2026