Explore 5,218 Used Subaru Forester Listings Near Windham, NY
Save search
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
8,131 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SLDHC5SH505737
$34,300
Great DealSingle ownerClean title
Rc Lacy Ford
Catskill, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
7,919 mi.
26 days on market
JF2SLDBCXSH496168
$31,600
Great DealSingle ownerClean title
Rc Lacy Ford
Catskill, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Wilderness
69,497 mi.
39 days on market
JF2SKAMCXPH538926
$26,900
Good DealSingle owner
Lacy Subaru
Catskill, NY
4.7
New listing
2023 Subaru Forester Wilderness
20,576 mi.
1 day on market
JF2SKAMC9PH402061
$37,800
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Lacy Subaru
Catskill, NY
4.7
2019 Subaru Forester Premium
61,662 mi.
29 days on market
JF2SKAGC7KH465518
$20,400
Fair DealClean title
Rc Lacy Ford
Catskill, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
42,164 mi.
8 days on market
JF2SKAEC7PH438071
$26,500
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Lacy Subaru
Catskill, NY
4.7
2018 Subaru Forester Premium
63,895 mi.
33 days on market
JF2SJAGC3JH508754
$19,900
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Rc Lacy Ford
Catskill, NY
4.8
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
122,457 mi.
6 days on market
JF2SKAJCXLH502782
Contact Dealer
B B Garage Llc
Catskill, NY
4.6
2012 Subaru Forester Premium
130,234 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SHADC3CH436943
$9,995
Fair Deal
Upstate Auto Inc
Germantown, NY
4.0
2015 Subaru Forester Premium
130,163 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SJADC3FH526179
$10,995
Fair Deal
Upstate Auto Inc
Germantown, NY
4.0
2006 Subaru Forester X
143,659 mi.
193 days on market
JF1SG676X6H745341
$5,700
Fair Deal
Spada Motors Llc
Saugerties, NY
5.0
2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X
146,053 mi.
193 days on market
JF2SH61699H719982
Contact Dealer
Spada Motors Llc
Saugerties, NY
5.0
2007 Subaru Forester X
146,460 mi.
75 days on market
JF1SG63647H732608
$5,495
Good Deal
Daystar Motors
Saugerties, NY
3.4
2005 Subaru Forester X
180,007 mi.
616 days on market
JF1SG63675G750975
$3,695
Great Deal
Daystar Motors
Saugerties, NY
3.4
2017 Subaru Forester Base
63,898 mi.
8 days on market
JF2SJABC1HH478073
$14,495
Fair Deal
Greenport Auto
Hudson, NY
4.3
2014 Subaru Forester Premium
67,251 mi.
8 days on market
JF2SJAEC9EH507553
$11,995
Fair Deal
Greenport Auto
Hudson, NY
4.3
2017 Subaru Forester Base
93,615 mi.
8 days on market
JF2SJABC4HH421611
Contact Dealer
Greenport Auto
Hudson, NY
4.3
2015 Subaru Forester Limited
122,653 mi.
37 days on market
JF2SJAHCXFH414442
$8,999
Great Deal
Broadway Garage Of Columbia County Inc
Hudson, NY
4.4
New listing
2015 Subaru Forester Base
18,532 mi.
1 day on market
JF2SJABC5FH426023
$16,900
Fair Deal
Broadway Garage Of Columbia County Inc
Hudson, NY
4.4
2018 Subaru Forester Premium
77,251 mi.
6 days on market
JF2SJAECXJH499716
$17,995
Fair Deal
Romeo Volkswagen Of Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.7
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
139,223 mi.
52 days on market
JF2SKAJC2LH542774
$11,995
Romeo Volkswagen Of Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.7
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
71,520 mi.
10 days on market
JF2SKAJC1LH456128
$19,300
Good DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
6,985 mi.
38 days on market
JF2SLDDC6SH496486
$31,900
Good DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2018 Subaru Forester Base
71,536 mi.
14 days on market
JF2SJAAC4JG476881
$16,400
Fair DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Limited
27,242 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SKAPC2PH423121
$28,900
Fair DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
13,350 mi.
118 days on market
JF2SLDHC4SH441061
$32,600
Good DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
45,027 mi.
52 days on market
JF2SKAJC4LH477393
$20,900
Fair DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Limited
6,984 mi.
119 days on market
JF2SLDRC5SH428964
$32,800
Good DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
8,131 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SLDHC5SH505737
$34,300
Great DealSingle ownerClean title
Rc Lacy Ford
Catskill, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
7,919 mi.
26 days on market
JF2SLDBCXSH496168
$31,600
Great DealSingle ownerClean title
Rc Lacy Ford
Catskill, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Wilderness
69,497 mi.
39 days on market
JF2SKAMCXPH538926
$26,900
Good DealSingle owner
Lacy Subaru
Catskill, NY
4.7
New listing
2023 Subaru Forester Wilderness
20,576 mi.
1 day on market
JF2SKAMC9PH402061
$37,800
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Lacy Subaru
Catskill, NY
4.7
2019 Subaru Forester Premium
61,662 mi.
29 days on market
JF2SKAGC7KH465518
$20,400
Fair DealClean title
Rc Lacy Ford
Catskill, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Premium
42,164 mi.
8 days on market
JF2SKAEC7PH438071
$26,500
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Lacy Subaru
Catskill, NY
4.7
2018 Subaru Forester Premium
63,895 mi.
33 days on market
JF2SJAGC3JH508754
$19,900
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Rc Lacy Ford
Catskill, NY
4.8
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
122,457 mi.
6 days on market
JF2SKAJCXLH502782
Contact Dealer
B B Garage Llc
Catskill, NY
4.6
2012 Subaru Forester Premium
130,234 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SHADC3CH436943
$9,995
Fair Deal
Upstate Auto Inc
Germantown, NY
4.0
2015 Subaru Forester Premium
130,163 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SJADC3FH526179
$10,995
Fair Deal
Upstate Auto Inc
Germantown, NY
4.0
2006 Subaru Forester X
143,659 mi.
193 days on market
JF1SG676X6H745341
$5,700
Fair Deal
Spada Motors Llc
Saugerties, NY
5.0
2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X
146,053 mi.
193 days on market
JF2SH61699H719982
Contact Dealer
Spada Motors Llc
Saugerties, NY
5.0
2007 Subaru Forester X
146,460 mi.
75 days on market
JF1SG63647H732608
$5,495
Good Deal
Daystar Motors
Saugerties, NY
3.4
2005 Subaru Forester X
180,007 mi.
616 days on market
JF1SG63675G750975
$3,695
Great Deal
Daystar Motors
Saugerties, NY
3.4
2017 Subaru Forester Base
63,898 mi.
8 days on market
JF2SJABC1HH478073
$14,495
Fair Deal
Greenport Auto
Hudson, NY
4.3
2014 Subaru Forester Premium
67,251 mi.
8 days on market
JF2SJAEC9EH507553
$11,995
Fair Deal
Greenport Auto
Hudson, NY
4.3
2017 Subaru Forester Base
93,615 mi.
8 days on market
JF2SJABC4HH421611
Contact Dealer
Greenport Auto
Hudson, NY
4.3
2015 Subaru Forester Limited
122,653 mi.
37 days on market
JF2SJAHCXFH414442
$8,999
Great Deal
Broadway Garage Of Columbia County Inc
Hudson, NY
4.4
New listing
2015 Subaru Forester Base
18,532 mi.
1 day on market
JF2SJABC5FH426023
$16,900
Fair Deal
Broadway Garage Of Columbia County Inc
Hudson, NY
4.4
2018 Subaru Forester Premium
77,251 mi.
6 days on market
JF2SJAECXJH499716
$17,995
Fair Deal
Romeo Volkswagen Of Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.7
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
139,223 mi.
52 days on market
JF2SKAJC2LH542774
$11,995
Romeo Volkswagen Of Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.7
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
71,520 mi.
10 days on market
JF2SKAJC1LH456128
$19,300
Good DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
6,985 mi.
38 days on market
JF2SLDDC6SH496486
$31,900
Good DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2018 Subaru Forester Base
71,536 mi.
14 days on market
JF2SJAAC4JG476881
$16,400
Fair DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2023 Subaru Forester Limited
27,242 mi.
4 days on market
JF2SKAPC2PH423121
$28,900
Fair DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
13,350 mi.
118 days on market
JF2SLDHC4SH441061
$32,600
Good DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
45,027 mi.
52 days on market
JF2SKAJC4LH477393
$20,900
Fair DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
2025 Subaru Forester Limited
6,984 mi.
119 days on market
JF2SLDRC5SH428964
$32,800
Good DealSingle owner
Curry Subaru Kingston
Kingston, NY
4.8
Find Used Subaru Forester in Windham, NY
We've got 5,218 Used Subaru Forester vehicles in Windham, NY, with prices running from $1,500 to $45,821. Mileage ranges up to 1,186,100 miles, so you can decide if you want something lightly driven or a more wallet-friendly option.