Explore 353 Used Tesla Listings Near Elma, NY
Save search
Sponsored
2021 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
89,874 mi.
37 days on market
5YJ3E1EB7MF009347
$19,995
Good Deal
112 Auto Plaza
Patchogue, NY
Sponsored
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
28,183 mi.
43 days on market
5YJYGDEF2MF252844
$34,995
Fair Deal
Euro Lux Auto
Hillside, NJ
Sponsored
2020 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
32,100 mi.
13 days on market
5YJYGDEF4LF034547
$29,995
Fair Deal
Blue Sky Automotive
Chicago, IL
2025 Tesla Model 3 Performance
4,321 mi.
35 days on market
5YJ3E1ET1SF034072
$49,021
Fair Deal
Laurel Valley Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
Latrobe, PA
5.0
2019 Tesla Model 3 Dual Motor All-Whel Drive Long Range
49,062 mi.
36 days on market
5YJ3E1EB6KF392971
$21,399
Great Deal
Hampstead Preowned
Hampstead, MD
4.7
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
30,588 mi.
36 days on market
7SAYGDEE6PF615600
$33,489
Fair DealSingle owner
Manheim Imports
Manheim, PA
4.8
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
63,827 mi.
37 days on market
7SAYGDEE4PF747657
$28,999
Good DealSingle owner
Tri County Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
Limerick, PA
4.4
2020 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
37,645 mi.
38 days on market
5YJYGDEE8LF028256
$27,500
Fair DealClean title
Wooster Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram
Wooster, OH
4.4
2022 Tesla Model S -
70,004 mi.
38 days on market
5YJSA1E51NF486925
$37,493
Good Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2026 Tesla Model Y Premium All-Wheel Drive
22,073 mi.
38 days on market
7SAYGDEE6TA388738
$44,489
Good DealSingle owner
Manheim Imports
Manheim, PA
4.8
2020 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
78,202 mi.
38 days on market
5YJ3E1EB8LF668889
$19,799
Great Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2023 Tesla Model S -
21,623 mi.
38 days on market
5YJSA1E55PF501865
$52,693
Fair DealSingle owner
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2023 Tesla Model Y Rear Wheel Drive
20,606 mi.
38 days on market
7SAYGDED1PF968706
$28,793
Great Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2021 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
64,084 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EB2MF859547
$22,995
Good Deal
Car Factory Of Latrobe
Latrobe, PA
4.2
2022 Tesla Model 3 Standard Range Plus
96,792 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EA7NF370831
$19,995
Good Deal
Xtreme Auto Sales
Spencerport, NY
4.2
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
72,189 mi.
39 days on market
7SAYGDEE3PF696670
$27,455
Good DealSingle owner
Harrisburg Mitsubishi
Harrisburg, PA
4.9
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
41,366 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EB9JF085759
$25,793
Fair Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2025 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
28,688 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EAXSF898164
$33,993
Good Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2020 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
65,231 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EBXLF639782
Contact Dealer
Prime Time Auto Financing
Redford Charter Township, MI
4.5
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
93,417 mi.
39 days on market
5YJYGDEE8MF144381
$24,675
Good Deal
Basil Toyota
Lockport, NY
4.6
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
78,358 mi.
39 days on market
5YJYGAEE2MF208428
$24,955
Good Deal
Taj Auto Mall
Bethlehem, PA
4.4
2023 Tesla Model S Standard Range
76,930 mi.
39 days on market
5YJSA1E50PF508755
$40,123
Good Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2023 Tesla Model S Plaid
20,481 mi.
40 days on market
5YJSA1E66PF511698
$73,999
Fair Deal
Trucks R Us
Central Square, NY
4.4
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
22,132 mi.
40 days on market
5YJ3E1EBXJF117649
Contact Dealer
A B Motors
Roseville, MI
4.4
2023 Tesla Model Y Rear Wheel Drive
45,262 mi.
40 days on market
7SAYGDEDXPF932772
$29,995
Good Deal
Bulldog Auto Sales
Schenectady, NY
4.6
2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
20,877 mi.
41 days on market
7SAYGDEF7NF319474
$32,928
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Lancaster Mitsubishi
East Petersburg, PA
4.9
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
122,381 mi.
41 days on market
5YJYGDEF9MF134788
$21,955
Good Deal
Star Auto Mall 512
Bethlehem, PA
4.2
2018 Tesla Model S 100D
100,287 mi.
41 days on market
5YJSA1E24JF290784
$21,955
Great DealClean title
Star Auto Mall 512
Bethlehem, PA
4.2
2016 Tesla Model X 75D
62,932 mi.
41 days on market
5YJXCBE2XGF022692
$21,955
Great Deal
Star Auto Mall 512
Bethlehem, PA
4.2
2017 Tesla Model S 75
102,400 mi.
42 days on market
5YJSA1E15HF228473
$16,995
Great Deal
724 Autosales
New Castle, PA
4.9
2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range Launch Series AWD
10,696 mi.
42 days on market
7SAYGDEE9TF338645
$52,594
Fair Deal
Fitzgerald Chevrolet Of Frederick
Frederick, MD
4.6
Sponsored
2021 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
89,874 mi.
37 days on market
5YJ3E1EB7MF009347
$19,995
Good Deal
112 Auto Plaza
Patchogue, NY
2025 Tesla Model 3 Performance
4,321 mi.
35 days on market
5YJ3E1ET1SF034072
$49,021
Fair Deal
Laurel Valley Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
Latrobe, PA
5.0
2019 Tesla Model 3 Dual Motor All-Whel Drive Long Range
49,062 mi.
36 days on market
5YJ3E1EB6KF392971
$21,399
Great Deal
Hampstead Preowned
Hampstead, MD
4.7
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
30,588 mi.
36 days on market
7SAYGDEE6PF615600
$33,489
Fair DealSingle owner
Manheim Imports
Manheim, PA
4.8
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
63,827 mi.
37 days on market
7SAYGDEE4PF747657
$28,999
Good DealSingle owner
Tri County Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
Limerick, PA
4.4
2020 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
37,645 mi.
38 days on market
5YJYGDEE8LF028256
$27,500
Fair DealClean title
Wooster Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram
Wooster, OH
4.4
2022 Tesla Model S -
70,004 mi.
38 days on market
5YJSA1E51NF486925
$37,493
Good Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2026 Tesla Model Y Premium All-Wheel Drive
22,073 mi.
38 days on market
7SAYGDEE6TA388738
$44,489
Good DealSingle owner
Manheim Imports
Manheim, PA
4.8
2020 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
78,202 mi.
38 days on market
5YJ3E1EB8LF668889
$19,799
Great Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2023 Tesla Model S -
21,623 mi.
38 days on market
5YJSA1E55PF501865
$52,693
Fair DealSingle owner
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2023 Tesla Model Y Rear Wheel Drive
20,606 mi.
38 days on market
7SAYGDED1PF968706
$28,793
Great Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2021 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
64,084 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EB2MF859547
$22,995
Good Deal
Car Factory Of Latrobe
Latrobe, PA
4.2
2022 Tesla Model 3 Standard Range Plus
96,792 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EA7NF370831
$19,995
Good Deal
Xtreme Auto Sales
Spencerport, NY
4.2
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
72,189 mi.
39 days on market
7SAYGDEE3PF696670
$27,455
Good DealSingle owner
Harrisburg Mitsubishi
Harrisburg, PA
4.9
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
41,366 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EB9JF085759
$25,793
Fair Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2025 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
28,688 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EAXSF898164
$33,993
Good Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2020 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
65,231 mi.
39 days on market
5YJ3E1EBXLF639782
Contact Dealer
Prime Time Auto Financing
Redford Charter Township, MI
4.5
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
93,417 mi.
39 days on market
5YJYGDEE8MF144381
$24,675
Good Deal
Basil Toyota
Lockport, NY
4.6
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
78,358 mi.
39 days on market
5YJYGAEE2MF208428
$24,955
Good Deal
Taj Auto Mall
Bethlehem, PA
4.4
2023 Tesla Model S Standard Range
76,930 mi.
39 days on market
5YJSA1E50PF508755
$40,123
Good Deal
North Coast Mitsubishi Bedford
Bedford, OH
4.6
2023 Tesla Model S Plaid
20,481 mi.
40 days on market
5YJSA1E66PF511698
$73,999
Fair Deal
Trucks R Us
Central Square, NY
4.4
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
22,132 mi.
40 days on market
5YJ3E1EBXJF117649
Contact Dealer
A B Motors
Roseville, MI
4.4
2023 Tesla Model Y Rear Wheel Drive
45,262 mi.
40 days on market
7SAYGDEDXPF932772
$29,995
Good Deal
Bulldog Auto Sales
Schenectady, NY
4.6
2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
20,877 mi.
41 days on market
7SAYGDEF7NF319474
$32,928
Fair DealSingle ownerClean title
Lancaster Mitsubishi
East Petersburg, PA
4.9
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
122,381 mi.
41 days on market
5YJYGDEF9MF134788
$21,955
Good Deal
Star Auto Mall 512
Bethlehem, PA
4.2
2018 Tesla Model S 100D
100,287 mi.
41 days on market
5YJSA1E24JF290784
$21,955
Great DealClean title
Star Auto Mall 512
Bethlehem, PA
4.2
2016 Tesla Model X 75D
62,932 mi.
41 days on market
5YJXCBE2XGF022692
$21,955
Great Deal
Star Auto Mall 512
Bethlehem, PA
4.2
2017 Tesla Model S 75
102,400 mi.
42 days on market
5YJSA1E15HF228473
$16,995
Great Deal
724 Autosales
New Castle, PA
4.9
2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range Launch Series AWD
10,696 mi.
42 days on market
7SAYGDEE9TF338645
$52,594
Fair Deal
Fitzgerald Chevrolet Of Frederick
Frederick, MD
4.6