Used tesla Cars for Sale near Shelter Island, NY
Save search
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
94,040 mi.
27 days on market
5YJ3E1EA6JF015711
$15,504
Fair Deal
Shoreline Cdjr
Old Saybrook, CT
4.7
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance
53,037 mi.
49 days on market
5YJYGDEF5MF262929
$24,995
Great Deal
Eagle Kia Of Riverhead
Riverhead, NY
4.2
2020 Tesla Model 3 Base
54,222 mi.
46 days on market
5YJ3E1EA5LF644413
$17,327
Good Deal
Apple Honda
Riverhead, NY
4.4
2024 Tesla Model Y Performance
30,844 mi.
18 days on market
7SAYGDEF8RA266609
$34,995
Great DealSingle owner
Riverhead Toyota
Riverhead, NY
4.4
2022 Tesla Model 3 Performance
18,445 mi.
3 days on market
5YJ3E1EC6NF105254
$28,211
Good Deal
Colonial Chevrolet
New London, CT
2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range
61,542 mi.
27 days on market
7SAYGDED2RF042477
$28,861
Good Deal
Colonial Cadillac
New London, CT
4.7
2023 Tesla Model 3 Base
50,581 mi.
5 days on market
5YJ3E1EA0PF473298
$23,371
Colonial Hyundai
New London, CT
3.0
2022 Tesla Model 3 Base
54,937 mi.
9 days on market
5YJ3E1EA1NF239975
$19,680
Good Deal
Whaling City Ford
New London, CT
3.9
2022 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
97,122 mi.
14 days on market
5YJ3E1EB5NF135675
$19,998
Fair Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2023 Tesla Model X Long Range
17,831 mi.
61 days on market
7SAXCDE52PF370401
$54,998
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range
10,417 mi.
85 days on market
7SAYGDEE7SA337134
$39,912
Good Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2022 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
38,054 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EB7NF321914
$25,500
Good Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2025 Tesla Model 3 Performance
28,155 mi.
41 days on market
5YJ3E1EA4SF894692
$32,590
Fair Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2024 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
8,828 mi.
21 days on market
5YJ3E1EB1RF736393
$34,998
Good Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range
183 mi.
91 days on market
7SAYGDEE8SA362057
$40,444
Good Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2016 Tesla Model S
83,556 mi.
823 days on market
5YJSA1E21GF153214
$20,495
Good Deal
Leejs Auto Sales Service
North Branford, CT
4.5
2021 Tesla Model 3 Base
26,000 mi.
272 days on market
5YJ3E1EB8MF033320
$24,995
Good Deal
Salem Auto Llc
Salem, CT
4.7
2016 Tesla Model S 90D
98,000 mi.
243 days on market
5YJSA1E27GF158885
$16,995
Fair Deal
Salem Auto Llc
Salem, CT
4.7
2022 Tesla Model X Long Range
68,496 mi.
7 days on market
7SAXCBE56NF334583
$43,995
Good Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2023 Tesla Model 3 Base
23,267 mi.
7 days on market
5YJ3E1EA0PF565771
$23,995
Good Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range
59,685 mi.
11 days on market
7SAYGDEE5NF322008
$24,995
Great Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2022 Tesla Model X Long Range
39,056 mi.
98 days on market
7SAXCDE50NF344196
$47,995
Fair Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range
27,458 mi.
40 days on market
5YJYGDEE9MF085230
$27,995
Good Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2022 Tesla Model Y Performance
26,120 mi.
33 days on market
7SAYGDEF7NF562637
$29,995
Good Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2014 Tesla Model S S
60,500 mi.
146 days on market
5YJSA1H1XEFP34372
$19,995
Good Deal
Affordable Transmissions Llc
East Haven, CT
4.3
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range
61,000 mi.
71 days on market
5YJYGDEE6MF079952
$33,000
Fair Deal
Melillo Motors Inc
North Haven, CT
3.4
2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range
28,528 mi.
7 days on market
7SAYGDEEXRA240861
$33,845
Fair Deal
Executive Chevrolet
Wallingford, CT
4.6
:max_bytes(500000):quality(100):fill(blur):sharpen(0.7,0.5,true):format(jpg)/110059/10386371/435951756829935.jpg)
2022 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
111,000 mi.
109 days on market
5YJ3E1EB6NF290946
$16,900
Great Deal
Imports Unlimited
Wallingford, CT
4.1
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
94,040 mi.
27 days on market
5YJ3E1EA6JF015711
$15,504
Fair Deal
Shoreline Cdjr
Old Saybrook, CT
4.7
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance
53,037 mi.
49 days on market
5YJYGDEF5MF262929
$24,995
Great Deal
Eagle Kia Of Riverhead
Riverhead, NY
4.2
2020 Tesla Model 3 Base
54,222 mi.
46 days on market
5YJ3E1EA5LF644413
$17,327
Good Deal
Apple Honda
Riverhead, NY
4.4
2024 Tesla Model Y Performance
30,844 mi.
18 days on market
7SAYGDEF8RA266609
$34,995
Great DealSingle owner
Riverhead Toyota
Riverhead, NY
4.4
2022 Tesla Model 3 Performance
18,445 mi.
3 days on market
5YJ3E1EC6NF105254
$28,211
Good Deal
Colonial Chevrolet
New London, CT
2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range
61,542 mi.
27 days on market
7SAYGDED2RF042477
$28,861
Good Deal
Colonial Cadillac
New London, CT
4.7
2023 Tesla Model 3 Base
50,581 mi.
5 days on market
5YJ3E1EA0PF473298
$23,371
Colonial Hyundai
New London, CT
3.0
2022 Tesla Model 3 Base
54,937 mi.
9 days on market
5YJ3E1EA1NF239975
$19,680
Good Deal
Whaling City Ford
New London, CT
3.9
2022 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
97,122 mi.
14 days on market
5YJ3E1EB5NF135675
$19,998
Fair Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2023 Tesla Model X Long Range
17,831 mi.
61 days on market
7SAXCDE52PF370401
$54,998
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range
10,417 mi.
85 days on market
7SAYGDEE7SA337134
$39,912
Good Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2022 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
38,054 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EB7NF321914
$25,500
Good Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2025 Tesla Model 3 Performance
28,155 mi.
41 days on market
5YJ3E1EA4SF894692
$32,590
Fair Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2024 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
8,828 mi.
21 days on market
5YJ3E1EB1RF736393
$34,998
Good Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range
183 mi.
91 days on market
7SAYGDEE8SA362057
$40,444
Good Deal
Premier Subaru
Branford, CT
4.3
2016 Tesla Model S
83,556 mi.
823 days on market
5YJSA1E21GF153214
$20,495
Good Deal
Leejs Auto Sales Service
North Branford, CT
4.5
2021 Tesla Model 3 Base
26,000 mi.
272 days on market
5YJ3E1EB8MF033320
$24,995
Good Deal
Salem Auto Llc
Salem, CT
4.7
2016 Tesla Model S 90D
98,000 mi.
243 days on market
5YJSA1E27GF158885
$16,995
Fair Deal
Salem Auto Llc
Salem, CT
4.7
2022 Tesla Model X Long Range
68,496 mi.
7 days on market
7SAXCBE56NF334583
$43,995
Good Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2023 Tesla Model 3 Base
23,267 mi.
7 days on market
5YJ3E1EA0PF565771
$23,995
Good Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range
59,685 mi.
11 days on market
7SAYGDEE5NF322008
$24,995
Great Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2022 Tesla Model X Long Range
39,056 mi.
98 days on market
7SAXCDE50NF344196
$47,995
Fair Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range
27,458 mi.
40 days on market
5YJYGDEE9MF085230
$27,995
Good Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2022 Tesla Model Y Performance
26,120 mi.
33 days on market
7SAYGDEF7NF562637
$29,995
Good Deal
Sound Auto Wholesalers
Branford, CT
4.8
2014 Tesla Model S S
60,500 mi.
146 days on market
5YJSA1H1XEFP34372
$19,995
Good Deal
Affordable Transmissions Llc
East Haven, CT
4.3
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range
61,000 mi.
71 days on market
5YJYGDEE6MF079952
$33,000
Fair Deal
Melillo Motors Inc
North Haven, CT
3.4
2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range
28,528 mi.
7 days on market
7SAYGDEEXRA240861
$33,845
Fair Deal
Executive Chevrolet
Wallingford, CT
4.6
2022 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
111,000 mi.
109 days on market
5YJ3E1EB6NF290946
$16,900
Great Deal
Imports Unlimited
Wallingford, CT
4.1
Nearby Tesla for Sale
Used Tesla in Shelter Island Heights, NYUsed Tesla in Greenport, NYUsed Tesla in East Marion, NYUsed Tesla in Sag Harbor, NYUsed Tesla in Orient, NYUsed Tesla in Southold, NYUsed Tesla in East Hampton, NYUsed Tesla in Peconic, NYUsed Tesla in Bridgehampton, NYUsed Tesla in Cutchogue, NYUsed Tesla in Wainscott, NYUsed Tesla in Water Mill, NYUsed Tesla in Sagaponack, NYUsed Tesla in New Suffolk, NYUsed Tesla in Amagansett, NYUsed Tesla in Mattituck, NYUsed Tesla in Southampton, NYUsed Tesla in Laurel, NYUsed Tesla in Jamesport, NYUsed Tesla in South Jamesport, NYUsed Tesla in Old Saybrook, CTUsed Tesla in South Lyme, CTUsed Tesla in Hampton Bays, NYUsed Tesla in Montauk, NYUsed Tesla in Aquebogue, NYUsed Tesla in Westbrook, CTUsed Tesla in Niantic, CTUsed Tesla in Riverhead, NYUsed Tesla in Amityville, NYUsed Tesla in Clinton, CTUsed Tesla in East Quogue, NYUsed Tesla in Centerbrook, CTUsed Tesla in Old Lyme, CTUsed Tesla in Essex, CTUsed Tesla in Ivoryton, CTUsed Tesla in New London, CTUsed Tesla in Deep River, CTUsed Tesla in East Lyme, CTUsed Tesla in Fishers Island, NYUsed Tesla in Quogue, NYUsed Tesla in Westhampton Beach, NYUsed Tesla in Hadlyme, CTUsed Tesla in Chester, CTUsed Tesla in Westhampton, NYUsed Tesla in Quaker Hill, CTUsed Tesla in Killingworth, CTUsed Tesla in Madison, CTUsed Tesla in Calverton, NYUsed Tesla in Groton, CTUsed Tesla in West Mystic, CTUsed Tesla in Speonk, NYUsed Tesla in Eastport, NYUsed Tesla in Remsenburg, NYUsed Tesla in Guilford, CTUsed Tesla in Mystic, CTUsed Tesla in East Haddam, CTUsed Tesla in Montville, CTUsed Tesla in Wading River, NYUsed Tesla in Manorville, NYUsed Tesla in Oakdale, CTUsed Tesla in Haddam, CTUsed Tesla in Gales Ferry, CTUsed Tesla in Old Mystic, CTUsed Tesla in East Moriches, NYUsed Tesla in Uncasville, CTUsed Tesla in North Branford, CTUsed Tesla in Salem, CTUsed Tesla in Waterford, CTUsed Tesla in Branford, CTUsed Tesla in Stonington, CTUsed Tesla in Center Moriches, NYUsed Tesla in Higganum, CTUsed Tesla in Ledyard, CTUsed Tesla in Shoreham, NYUsed Tesla in Moodus, CTUsed Tesla in Pawcatuck, CTUsed Tesla in Ridge, NYUsed Tesla in Moriches, NYUsed Tesla in Northford, CTUsed Tesla in East Haven, CTUsed Tesla in Upton, NYUsed Tesla in Mastic, NYUsed Tesla in Durham, CTUsed Tesla in Colchester, CTUsed Tesla in Rocky Point, NYUsed Tesla in Westerly, RIUsed Tesla in Mashantucket, CTUsed Tesla in Bozrah, CTUsed Tesla in Mastic Beach, NYUsed Tesla in Shirley, NYUsed Tesla in Yaphank, NYUsed Tesla in Sound Beach, NYUsed Tesla in East Hampton, CTUsed Tesla in Norwich, CTUsed Tesla in Preston, CTUsed Tesla in Middle Island, NYUsed Tesla in Yantic, CTUsed Tesla in Miller Place, NYUsed Tesla in North Stonington, CT