121 Used Tesla Model S for Sale Near New Albany, IN

2021 Tesla Model S Performance's photo
VerifiedDealer partner

2021 Tesla Model S

Performance•70,132 mi•
5YJSA1E42MF425542
$37,733
Deal Gauge
LocationLansing, IL•Guaranteed Motor Cars
2017 Tesla Model S 90D's photo
VerifiedDealer partner

2017 Tesla Model S

90D•52,553 mi•
5YJSA1E28HF208761
$29,895
Deal Gauge
LocationGriffith, IN•Smart Buy Auto Finance
2015 Tesla Model S 85D's photo
New listing

2015 Tesla Model S

85D•60,555 mi•
5YJSA1H2XFFP74087
$16,500
LocationGriffith, IN•Lake Motor Group Llc
2015 Tesla Model S 85D's photo
New listing

2015 Tesla Model S

85D•91,374 mi•
5YJSA1H22FFP76321
$19,590
LocationUniversity Park, IL•Carvana University Park
2017 Tesla Model S 100D's photo

2017 Tesla Model S

100D•56,189 mi•
5YJSA1E27HF216902
$29,962
LocationElizabethtown, KY•Swope Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
2017 Tesla Model S 75D's photo

2017 Tesla Model S

75D•91,323 mi•
5YJSA1E29HF230669
$18,993
LocationWest Harrison, IN•Whitewater Motors
2021 Tesla Model S Plaid's photo

2021 Tesla Model S

Plaid•21,234 mi•
5YJSA1E68MF438068
$55,402
LocationBloomington, IL•Sam Leman Ford
2022 Tesla Model S Plaid's photo

2022 Tesla Model S

Plaid•24,425 mi•
5YJSA1E65NF479789
$76,100
LocationFranklin, TN•Tesla Nashville
2024 Tesla Model S Plaid's photo

2024 Tesla Model S

Plaid•22,712 mi•
5YJSA1E65RF545053
$94,990
LocationBrentwood, TN•Evauto Ev Auto Brentwood
2020 Tesla Model S Performance's photo

2020 Tesla Model S

Performance•10,891 mi•
5YJSA1E40LF368983
$47,990
LocationGreenfield, IN•Carvana Greenfield
2022 Tesla Model S Long Range's photo

2022 Tesla Model S

Long Range•14,628 mi•
5YJSA1E53NF490295
$51,990
LocationUniversity Park, IL•Carvana University Park
2021 Tesla Model S Long Range Plus's photo

2021 Tesla Model S

Long Range Plus•53,100 mi•
5YJSA1E50MF434264
$47,990
LocationNew Albany, IN•Hypercars
2020 Tesla Model S Performance's photo

2020 Tesla Model S

Performance•32,494 mi•
5YJSA1E49LF416674
$40,500
LocationNashville, TN•Mercedes Benz Of Music City Nashville
2018 Tesla Model S 100D's photo

2018 Tesla Model S

100D•54,575 mi•
5YJSA1E26JF272738
$28,990
LocationTrenton, OH•Carvana Trenton
2025 Tesla Model S Base's photo

2025 Tesla Model S

Base•15,657 mi•
5YJSA1E55SF550380
$84,990
LocationHeath, OH•Carvana Heath
2015 Tesla Model S 85D's photo

2015 Tesla Model S

85D•46,297 mi•
5YJSA1H28FF084824
$22,990
LocationUniversity Park, IL•Carvana University Park
2014 Tesla Model S 85 kWh's photo

2014 Tesla Model S

85 kWh•99,988 mi•
5YJSA1H11EFP61007
$12,500
LocationGriffith, IN•Lake Motor Group Llc
2018 Tesla Model S P100D's photo

2018 Tesla Model S

P100D•16,293 mi•
5YJSA1E42JF287089
$41,590
LocationUniversity Park, IL•Carvana University Park
2017 Tesla Model S 90D's photo

2017 Tesla Model S

90D•47,031 mi•
5YJSA1E22HF199670
$26,590
LocationUniversity Park, IL•Carvana University Park
2013 Tesla Model S 85 kWh's photo

2013 Tesla Model S

85 kWh•96,050 mi•
5YJSA1CN0DFP05567
$13,299
LocationColumbus, OH•Tiger Auto Sales
2022 Tesla Model S Base's photo

2022 Tesla Model S

Base•96,117 mi•
5YJSA1E56NF470347
$35,943
LocationColumbus, OH•Auto Boutique Ohio
2014 Tesla Model S 85 kWh's photo

2014 Tesla Model S

85 kWh•128,140 mi•
5YJSA1H14EFP61597
$13,240
LocationWarsaw, IN•Model 1 Ford Of Warsaw
2013 Tesla Model S 85 kWh's photo

2013 Tesla Model S

85 kWh•133,344 mi•
5YJSA1CN4DFP12974
$12,000
LocationColumbus, OH•Tiger Auto Sales
2014 Tesla Model S 85 kWh's photo

2014 Tesla Model S

85 kWh•117,453 mi•
5YJSA1H23EFP62930
$14,429
LocationWest Chester, OH•Unlimited Auto Group
2020 Tesla Model S Long Range Plus's photo

2020 Tesla Model S

Long Range Plus•10,004 mi•
5YJSA1E20LF409241
$29,995
LocationRussell Springs, KY•Don Franklin Gmc Russell Springs
2018 Tesla Model S P100D's photo

2018 Tesla Model S

P100D•50,831 mi•
5YJSA1E48JF272189
$34,990
LocationMarysville, OH•Performance Luxury Sport
2021 Tesla Model S Plaid's photo

2021 Tesla Model S

Plaid•36,990 mi•
5YJSA1E61MF432127
$59,339
LocationColumbus, OH•Germain Cadillac Of Easton
2023 Tesla Model S Plaid's photo

2023 Tesla Model S

Plaid•40,446 mi•
5YJSA1E60PF524754
$73,996
LocationDwight, IL•Dwight Ford
2013 Tesla Model S Performance's photo

2013 Tesla Model S

Performance•129,914 mi•
5YJSA1DP6DFP08859
$13,139
LocationJeffersontown, KY•Bachman Chevrolet
2019 Tesla Model S Long Range's photo

2019 Tesla Model S

Long Range•68,669 mi•
5YJSA1E20KF306562
$27,750
LocationCrestwood, KY•Glenn Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
123
Next

Showing 1 - 28 from 121 results

121

Model S for sale in New Albany

$25,616

Median local price

77

New Albany-area dealerships

Tesla Model S overview

Shop 121 used Tesla Model S listings for sale, priced from $9,495 to $138,204 across 77 dealerships. The median asking price is $25,616, with an average mileage of 74,077 miles. Inventory spans model years 2012 to 2026 and is strongest for 2017–2021, with 63 listings.

About Tesla Model S

Frequently Asked Questions

How many used Tesla Model S listings are for sale?

There are 121 used Tesla Model S listings for sale from 77 dealerships, priced from $9,495 to $138,204.

How much does a used Tesla Model S cost?

The median asking price for a used Tesla Model S is $25,616. Listings range from $9,495 to $138,204. The average mileage is 74,077 miles.

What is the cheapest used Tesla Model S for sale?

The lowest-priced listing is a 2013 Tesla Model S 85 kWh at $9,495 with 150,269 miles in Indianapolis, IN.

What model years are available?

Used Tesla Model S inventory spans model years 2012 to 2026. The 2017–2021 model years are the most available, with 63 listings.

What trim levels are available for the Tesla Model S?

The Tesla Model S is available in the following trim levels:

Used Tesla Model S by trim

Used Tesla Model S in New Albany by year

Used Tesla Model S in nearby metros