Used tesla Cars for Sale near Bay Shore, NY
Save search
2018 Tesla Model S 75D
106,006 mi.
32 days on market
5YJSA1E23JF262572
$15,777
Good Deal
West Islip Auto Sales
West Islip, NY
4.8
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range
45,015 mi.
21 days on market
7SAYGDEE2NA009995
$27,495
Great DealSingle owner
Volkswagen Of West Islip
West Islip, NY
4.3
2018 Tesla Model X 75D
8,869 mi.
2166 days on market
5YJXCDE25JF112884
$69,990
Good Deal
Drive Auto Sales
Bay Shore, NY
5.0
2017 Tesla Model S 75D
31,234 mi.
1982 days on market
5YJSA1E27HF187322
$49,990
Drive Auto Sales
Bay Shore, NY
5.0
2016 Tesla Model S 90D
27,774 mi.
1806 days on market
5YJSA1E23GF128489
$41,990
Good Deal
Drive Auto Sales
Bay Shore, NY
5.0
2014 Tesla Model S S
42,730 mi.
1809 days on market
5YJSA1H15EFP55842
$31,990
Drive Auto Sales
Bay Shore, NY
5.0
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range
39,074 mi.
26 days on market
7SAYGDEE3PA105671
$28,995
Good Deal
Mp Motors Inc
West Babylon, NY
5.0
2020 Tesla Model 3 Base
39,865 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EB0LF795619
$26,995
Mp Motors Inc
West Babylon, NY
5.0
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range
129,788 mi.
110 days on market
5YJYGDEE9MF201445
Contact Dealer
Imperial Auto Mall
West Babylon, NY
4.5
2018 Tesla Model S 75D
67,387 mi.
39 days on market
5YJSA1E2XJF280647
$18,595
Good Deal
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range
50,000 mi.
15 days on market
7SAYGDEE8NF316848
$23,595
Good DealClean title
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2018 Tesla Model S 75D
58,682 mi.
25 days on market
5YJSA1E22JF275863
$16,995
Great Deal
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2022 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
40,111 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EB8NF175863
$21,895
Single ownerClean title
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance
63,087 mi.
59 days on market
5YJYGDEF4MF252120
$19,695
Great DealSingle owner
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance
57,332 mi.
47 days on market
5YJYGDEF9MF242991
$22,595
Good DealClean title
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2018 Tesla Model X 75D
46,283 mi.
13 days on market
5YJXCBE23JF132507
$22,995
Great DealSingle owner
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2018 Tesla Model S 100D
27,054 mi.
89 days on market
5YJSA1E26JF284758
$38,900
Clean title
Motorcar Classics
Farmingdale, NY
4.9
2021 Tesla Model 3 Base
77,602 mi.
8 days on market
5YJ3E1EB4MF869173
$20,035
Habberstad Kia
Huntington, NY
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range
48,163 mi.
8 days on market
7SAYGDEE6NF378071
$25,737
Habberstad Kia
Huntington, NY
2015 Tesla Model S 85D
62,102 mi.
546 days on market
5YJSA1H23FFP71290
Contact Dealer
Long Island Cars Direct
Bohemia, NY
5.0
2016 Tesla Model S
107,569 mi.
3 days on market
5YJSA1E27GF122873
$16,900
Single ownerClean title
Stoler Lexus
Farmingdale, NY
4.7
2024 Tesla Model 3 Base
11,712 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EAXRF868687
$29,987
Single owner
Empire Toyota Of Huntington
Huntington Station, NY
4.4
2024 Tesla Cybertruck Base
18,917 mi.
33 days on market
7G2CEHED0RA005233
$75,741
Great DealSingle owner
Empire Automotive Group
Huntington Station, NY
2.5
2023 Tesla Model Y Performance
24,154 mi.
76 days on market
7SAYGDEF0PF869523
$30,536
Good Deal
Habberstad Bmw
Huntington Station, NY
4.7
2020 Tesla Model 3 Base
59,530 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EA9LF658959
$18,977
Good DealClean title
South Shore Auto Brokers Sales
Massapequa, NY
4.8
2023 Tesla Model S Plaid
32,173 mi.
11 days on market
5YJSA1E61PF511835
$60,988
Great DealSingle ownerClean title
Lexus Of Smithtown
Saint James, NY
4.8
Photos coming soon
2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range
0 mi.
4 days on market
7SAYGAEE0SF224837
Contact Dealer
Single owner
Sarant Cadillac
Farmingdale, NY
4.4
2022 Tesla Model Y Performance
34,865 mi.
24 days on market
7SAYGDEF9NF523841
$26,496
Good DealSingle ownerClean title
Chevrolet Of Smithtown
Saint James, NY
4.0
2018 Tesla Model S 75D
106,006 mi.
32 days on market
5YJSA1E23JF262572
$15,777
Good Deal
West Islip Auto Sales
West Islip, NY
4.8
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range
45,015 mi.
21 days on market
7SAYGDEE2NA009995
$27,495
Great DealSingle owner
Volkswagen Of West Islip
West Islip, NY
4.3
2018 Tesla Model X 75D
8,869 mi.
2166 days on market
5YJXCDE25JF112884
$69,990
Good Deal
Drive Auto Sales
Bay Shore, NY
5.0
2017 Tesla Model S 75D
31,234 mi.
1982 days on market
5YJSA1E27HF187322
$49,990
Drive Auto Sales
Bay Shore, NY
5.0
2016 Tesla Model S 90D
27,774 mi.
1806 days on market
5YJSA1E23GF128489
$41,990
Good Deal
Drive Auto Sales
Bay Shore, NY
5.0
2014 Tesla Model S S
42,730 mi.
1809 days on market
5YJSA1H15EFP55842
$31,990
Drive Auto Sales
Bay Shore, NY
5.0
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range
39,074 mi.
26 days on market
7SAYGDEE3PA105671
$28,995
Good Deal
Mp Motors Inc
West Babylon, NY
5.0
2020 Tesla Model 3 Base
39,865 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EB0LF795619
$26,995
Mp Motors Inc
West Babylon, NY
5.0
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range
129,788 mi.
110 days on market
5YJYGDEE9MF201445
Contact Dealer
Imperial Auto Mall
West Babylon, NY
4.5
2018 Tesla Model S 75D
67,387 mi.
39 days on market
5YJSA1E2XJF280647
$18,595
Good Deal
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range
50,000 mi.
15 days on market
7SAYGDEE8NF316848
$23,595
Good DealClean title
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2018 Tesla Model S 75D
58,682 mi.
25 days on market
5YJSA1E22JF275863
$16,995
Great Deal
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2022 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
40,111 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EB8NF175863
$21,895
Single ownerClean title
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance
63,087 mi.
59 days on market
5YJYGDEF4MF252120
$19,695
Great DealSingle owner
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance
57,332 mi.
47 days on market
5YJYGDEF9MF242991
$22,595
Good DealClean title
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2018 Tesla Model X 75D
46,283 mi.
13 days on market
5YJXCBE23JF132507
$22,995
Great DealSingle owner
Pristine Mitsubishi
Commack, NY
4.0
2018 Tesla Model S 100D
27,054 mi.
89 days on market
5YJSA1E26JF284758
$38,900
Clean title
Motorcar Classics
Farmingdale, NY
4.9
2021 Tesla Model 3 Base
77,602 mi.
8 days on market
5YJ3E1EB4MF869173
$20,035
Habberstad Kia
Huntington, NY
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range
48,163 mi.
8 days on market
7SAYGDEE6NF378071
$25,737
Habberstad Kia
Huntington, NY
2015 Tesla Model S 85D
62,102 mi.
546 days on market
5YJSA1H23FFP71290
Contact Dealer
Long Island Cars Direct
Bohemia, NY
5.0
2016 Tesla Model S
107,569 mi.
3 days on market
5YJSA1E27GF122873
$16,900
Single ownerClean title
Stoler Lexus
Farmingdale, NY
4.7
2024 Tesla Model 3 Base
11,712 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EAXRF868687
$29,987
Single owner
Empire Toyota Of Huntington
Huntington Station, NY
4.4
2024 Tesla Cybertruck Base
18,917 mi.
33 days on market
7G2CEHED0RA005233
$75,741
Great DealSingle owner
Empire Automotive Group
Huntington Station, NY
2.5
2023 Tesla Model Y Performance
24,154 mi.
76 days on market
7SAYGDEF0PF869523
$30,536
Good Deal
Habberstad Bmw
Huntington Station, NY
4.7
2020 Tesla Model 3 Base
59,530 mi.
25 days on market
5YJ3E1EA9LF658959
$18,977
Good DealClean title
South Shore Auto Brokers Sales
Massapequa, NY
4.8
2023 Tesla Model S Plaid
32,173 mi.
11 days on market
5YJSA1E61PF511835
$60,988
Great DealSingle ownerClean title
Lexus Of Smithtown
Saint James, NY
4.8
Photos coming soon
2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range
0 mi.
4 days on market
7SAYGAEE0SF224837
Contact Dealer
Single owner
Sarant Cadillac
Farmingdale, NY
4.4
2022 Tesla Model Y Performance
34,865 mi.
24 days on market
7SAYGDEF9NF523841
$26,496
Good DealSingle ownerClean title
Chevrolet Of Smithtown
Saint James, NY
4.0
Nearby Tesla for Sale
Used Tesla in Brightwaters, NYUsed Tesla in West Islip, NYUsed Tesla in Islip, NYUsed Tesla in North Babylon, NYUsed Tesla in Brentwood, NYUsed Tesla in Deer Park, NYUsed Tesla in East Islip, NYUsed Tesla in Central Islip, NYUsed Tesla in West Babylon, NYUsed Tesla in Islip Terrace, NYUsed Tesla in Great River, NYUsed Tesla in Wyandanch, NYUsed Tesla in Lindenhurst, NYUsed Tesla in Hauppauge, NYUsed Tesla in Islandia, NYUsed Tesla in Oakdale, NYUsed Tesla in Commack, NYUsed Tesla in Huntington Station, NYUsed Tesla in Bohemia, NYUsed Tesla in Copiague, NYUsed Tesla in Ocean Beach, NYUsed Tesla in Farmingdale, NYUsed Tesla in West Sayville, NYUsed Tesla in Melville, NYUsed Tesla in Babylon, NYUsed Tesla in Smithtown, NYUsed Tesla in East Northport, NYUsed Tesla in Sayville, NYUsed Tesla in Ronkonkoma, NYUsed Tesla in Nesconset, NYUsed Tesla in Old Bethpage, NYUsed Tesla in Massapequa Park, NYUsed Tesla in Greenlawn, NYUsed Tesla in Kings Park, NYUsed Tesla in Plainview, NYUsed Tesla in Bayport, NYUsed Tesla in Massapequa, NYUsed Tesla in Holbrook, NYUsed Tesla in Bethpage, NYUsed Tesla in Lake Grove, NYUsed Tesla in Saint James, NYUsed Tesla in Blue Point, NYUsed Tesla in Woodbury, NYUsed Tesla in Centerport, NYUsed Tesla in Seaford, NYUsed Tesla in Northport, NYUsed Tesla in Holtsville, NYUsed Tesla in Huntington, NYUsed Tesla in Cold Spring Harbor, NYUsed Tesla in Levittown, NYUsed Tesla in Centereach, NYUsed Tesla in Wantagh, NYUsed Tesla in Stony Brook, NYUsed Tesla in Farmingville, NYUsed Tesla in Syosset, NYUsed Tesla in Patchogue, NYUsed Tesla in Bellmore, NYUsed Tesla in Selden, NYUsed Tesla in Jericho, NYUsed Tesla in East Meadow, NYUsed Tesla in Merrick, NYUsed Tesla in East Norwich, NYUsed Tesla in Medford, NYUsed Tesla in Oyster Bay, NYUsed Tesla in East Setauket, NYUsed Tesla in Coram, NYUsed Tesla in Bellport, NYUsed Tesla in Roosevelt, NYUsed Tesla in Uniondale, NYUsed Tesla in Port Jefferson Station, NYUsed Tesla in Freeport, NYUsed Tesla in Hempstead, NYUsed Tesla in Hicksville, NYUsed Tesla in Port Washington, NYUsed Tesla in Westbury, NYUsed Tesla in Old Westbury, NYUsed Tesla in Glen Head, NYUsed Tesla in Carle Place, NYUsed Tesla in Port Jefferson, NYUsed Tesla in Mill Neck, NYUsed Tesla in Baldwin, NYUsed Tesla in Brookhaven, NYUsed Tesla in Mount Sinai, NYUsed Tesla in Point Lookout, NYUsed Tesla in Middle Island, NYUsed Tesla in Garden City, NYUsed Tesla in Bayville, NYUsed Tesla in Mineola, NYUsed Tesla in Greenvale, NYUsed Tesla in Locust Valley, NYUsed Tesla in Yaphank, NYUsed Tesla in Williston Park, NYUsed Tesla in Roslyn Heights, NYUsed Tesla in Rockville Centre, NYUsed Tesla in West Hempstead, NYUsed Tesla in Albertson, NYUsed Tesla in Miller Place, NYUsed Tesla in Shirley, NYUsed Tesla in Glenwood Landing, NY