1,661 Used Tesla Cars for Sale Near Bay Shore, NY
Save search
Sponsored
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
30,143 mi.
16 days on market
5YJ3E1EA7PF556453
$25,791
Fair Deal
Michaels Autos
Orlando, FL
Sponsored
2019 Tesla Model 3
93,511 mi.
69 days on market
5YJ3E1EB4KF487173
$19,900
Great DealClean title
Evolving Motors Inc
Norwalk, CA
Sponsored
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
84,625 mi.
14 days on market
5YJ3E1EA2JF038838
$18,999
Good Deal
Bucketbuddy Auto Llc
Sacramento, CA
2024 Tesla Model 3 -
34,095 mi.
13 days on market
5YJ3E1EAXRF722211
$28,170
Good Deal
Turn Auto Mall
New Hyde Park, NY
4.6
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
90,139 mi.
57 days on market
5YJYGDEF6MF251762
$19,195
Good Deal
Victory Cars Central
Levittown, NY
4.5
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
88,389 mi.
6 days on market
5YJYGDEE9MF185134
$22,800
Great Deal
Mr Car Group
Elmhurst, NY
5.0
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
29,370 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA5PF467450
Contact Dealer
Clean title
Ecoauto Llc
Tewksbury, MA
4.7
2026 Tesla Model Y Premium Rear Wheel Drive
17,731 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDED2TA429311
$43,493
Good DealSingle owner
Faulkner Bmw
Lancaster, PA
4.7
2019 Tesla Model 3 Dual Motor All-Whel Drive Long Range
100,207 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EB0KF493228
$18,994
Good Deal
Prestige Toyota Of Ramsey
Ramsey, NJ
4.5
2018 Tesla Model 3
26,910 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA0JF056349
$25,594
Fair Deal
Toyota Of Stamford
Stamford, CT
4.6
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
29,261 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EAXPF508641
$22,500
Great Deal
Tesla Paramus
Paramus, NJ
3.6
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
73,416 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEEXPA121544
$29,200
Good Deal
Tesla Cherry Hill
Cherry Hill, NJ
3.6
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
36,268 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA4PF580094
$22,300
Great Deal
Tesla Mount Kisco
Mount Kisco, NY
3.6
2023 Tesla Model S
57,324 mi.
2 days on market
5YJSA1E57PF505786
$56,100
Fair Deal
Tesla Warminster
Warminster, PA
3.6
2022 Tesla Model X Long Range
66,562 mi.
2 days on market
7SAXCBE59NF359137
$58,200
Tesla Lawrence Township
Lawrence Township, NJ
3.6
Photos coming soon
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
90,000 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA7JF025583
$17,950
Good Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
Photos coming soon
2022 Tesla Model 3 Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
115,000 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1ECXNF297696
$22,350
Good Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
135,946 mi.
2 days on market
5YJYGDEF0MF124411
$23,999
Good Deal
Auto Market Street
Paterson, NJ
4.5
2021 Tesla Model 3 Standard Range Plus
73,280 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA6MF084385
$20,799
Good Deal
Bm Motor Cars
Linden, NJ
4.3
2023 Tesla Model 3 Performance
24,480 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EC9PF705267
$33,881
Fair Deal
Koch 33 Toyota
Easton, PA
4.6
2023 Tesla Model X Plaid
49,182 mi.
2 days on market
7SAXCBE68PF404046
Contact Dealer
Chevrolet Of Bloomsburg
Bloomsburg, PA
4.5
2023 Tesla Model Y
36,471 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEF1PD758639
$30,595
Euro Lux Auto
Hillside, NJ
4.6
2023 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
47,339 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEF4PF782935
$33,797
Good DealSingle owner
Ourisman Lexus Of Rockville
Derwood, MD
4.7
Photos coming soon
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
32,459 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA3PF547538
$25,950
Fair Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
Photos coming soon
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
8,000 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA4PF548696
$26,390
Fair Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
Photos coming soon
2020 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
32,000 mi.
2 days on market
5YJYGDEF1LF001263
$28,490
Fair Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
Photos coming soon
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
99,000 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEE2NF451209
$24,750
Good Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
2025 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
20,483 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA4SF972775
$34,995
Great Deal
Automotive Avenues
Wall Township, NJ
4.8
2022 Tesla Model X Long Range
6,772 mi.
2 days on market
7SAXCDE51NF339993
$54,495
Fair Deal
Automotive Avenues
Wall Township, NJ
4.8
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
56,941 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEEXNF564129
$31,495
Fair Deal
1 A Auto Sales
Walpole, MA
4.2
2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
95,661 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEF5NF517471
Contact Dealer
Clean title
Metrowest Auto Sales
Worcester, MA
4.1
2021 Tesla Model S Plaid
51,670 mi.
2 days on market
5YJSA1E69MF435728
$53,485
Good Deal
Faulkner Buick Gmc
Feasterville-Trevose, PA
4.5
2021 Tesla Model 3 Standard Range Plus
58,324 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA8MF923548
$22,300
Fair Deal
Tesla Springfield
Springfield, NJ
3.6
2022 Tesla Model S
50,552 mi.
2 days on market
5YJSA1E53NF470208
$51,200
Fair Deal
Tesla Rockville
Rockville, MD
3.6
Sponsored
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
30,143 mi.
16 days on market
5YJ3E1EA7PF556453
$25,791
Fair Deal
Michaels Autos
Orlando, FL
2024 Tesla Model 3 -
34,095 mi.
13 days on market
5YJ3E1EAXRF722211
$28,170
Good Deal
Turn Auto Mall
New Hyde Park, NY
4.6
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
90,139 mi.
57 days on market
5YJYGDEF6MF251762
$19,195
Good Deal
Victory Cars Central
Levittown, NY
4.5
2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
88,389 mi.
6 days on market
5YJYGDEE9MF185134
$22,800
Great Deal
Mr Car Group
Elmhurst, NY
5.0
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
29,370 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA5PF467450
Contact Dealer
Clean title
Ecoauto Llc
Tewksbury, MA
4.7
2026 Tesla Model Y Premium Rear Wheel Drive
17,731 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDED2TA429311
$43,493
Good DealSingle owner
Faulkner Bmw
Lancaster, PA
4.7
2019 Tesla Model 3 Dual Motor All-Whel Drive Long Range
100,207 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EB0KF493228
$18,994
Good Deal
Prestige Toyota Of Ramsey
Ramsey, NJ
4.5
2018 Tesla Model 3
26,910 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA0JF056349
$25,594
Fair Deal
Toyota Of Stamford
Stamford, CT
4.6
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
29,261 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EAXPF508641
$22,500
Great Deal
Tesla Paramus
Paramus, NJ
3.6
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
73,416 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEEXPA121544
$29,200
Good Deal
Tesla Cherry Hill
Cherry Hill, NJ
3.6
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
36,268 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA4PF580094
$22,300
Great Deal
Tesla Mount Kisco
Mount Kisco, NY
3.6
2023 Tesla Model S
57,324 mi.
2 days on market
5YJSA1E57PF505786
$56,100
Fair Deal
Tesla Warminster
Warminster, PA
3.6
2022 Tesla Model X Long Range
66,562 mi.
2 days on market
7SAXCBE59NF359137
$58,200
Tesla Lawrence Township
Lawrence Township, NJ
3.6
Photos coming soon
2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
90,000 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA7JF025583
$17,950
Good Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
Photos coming soon
2022 Tesla Model 3 Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
115,000 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1ECXNF297696
$22,350
Good Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
135,946 mi.
2 days on market
5YJYGDEF0MF124411
$23,999
Good Deal
Auto Market Street
Paterson, NJ
4.5
2021 Tesla Model 3 Standard Range Plus
73,280 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA6MF084385
$20,799
Good Deal
Bm Motor Cars
Linden, NJ
4.3
2023 Tesla Model 3 Performance
24,480 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EC9PF705267
$33,881
Fair Deal
Koch 33 Toyota
Easton, PA
4.6
2023 Tesla Model X Plaid
49,182 mi.
2 days on market
7SAXCBE68PF404046
Contact Dealer
Chevrolet Of Bloomsburg
Bloomsburg, PA
4.5
2023 Tesla Model Y
36,471 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEF1PD758639
$30,595
Euro Lux Auto
Hillside, NJ
4.6
2023 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
47,339 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEF4PF782935
$33,797
Good DealSingle owner
Ourisman Lexus Of Rockville
Derwood, MD
4.7
Photos coming soon
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
32,459 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA3PF547538
$25,950
Fair Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
Photos coming soon
2023 Tesla Model 3 -
8,000 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA4PF548696
$26,390
Fair Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
Photos coming soon
2020 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
32,000 mi.
2 days on market
5YJYGDEF1LF001263
$28,490
Fair Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
Photos coming soon
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
99,000 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEE2NF451209
$24,750
Good Deal
Easterns Automotive Group
Alexandria, VA
4.8
2025 Tesla Model 3 Long Range
20,483 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA4SF972775
$34,995
Great Deal
Automotive Avenues
Wall Township, NJ
4.8
2022 Tesla Model X Long Range
6,772 mi.
2 days on market
7SAXCDE51NF339993
$54,495
Fair Deal
Automotive Avenues
Wall Township, NJ
4.8
2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
56,941 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEEXNF564129
$31,495
Fair Deal
1 A Auto Sales
Walpole, MA
4.2
2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive
95,661 mi.
2 days on market
7SAYGDEF5NF517471
Contact Dealer
Clean title
Metrowest Auto Sales
Worcester, MA
4.1
2021 Tesla Model S Plaid
51,670 mi.
2 days on market
5YJSA1E69MF435728
$53,485
Good Deal
Faulkner Buick Gmc
Feasterville-Trevose, PA
4.5
2021 Tesla Model 3 Standard Range Plus
58,324 mi.
2 days on market
5YJ3E1EA8MF923548
$22,300
Fair Deal
Tesla Springfield
Springfield, NJ
3.6
2022 Tesla Model S
50,552 mi.
2 days on market
5YJSA1E53NF470208
$51,200
Fair Deal
Tesla Rockville
Rockville, MD
3.6